Why Did So Many Black Women Die? The Jonestown Massacre at 35

All rights reserved by Peoples Temple / Jonestown Gallery

All rights reserved by Peoples Temple / Jonestown Gallery

By Guest Contributor Sikivu Hutchinson; originally published at Religion Dispatches

Thirty-five years ago, on November 19, 1978, 73 year-old Hyacinth Thrash awoke to a nightmare in the jungles of Guyana.  Nine hundred and eighteen people from her Peoples Temple church lay dead before her eyes, poisoned by a lethal cocktail of cyanide and fruit punch.  The images from this gothic scene of carnage have become indelible. Bodies stretch into the distance in rows, face down on the ground.  They are overwhelmingly black bodies, clad in simple workaday clothing. Rendered “anonymous”, they represent complex extended families of children, elderly women, young women, mothers, grandmothers, aunts, sisters and nieces.  They came to Jonestown, Guyana from communities all across the U.S., drawn by the utopic promise of life in a communal settlement envisioned by a charismatic white messiah as a socialist refuge from American racial apartheid. One of the most haunting scenes from the massacre’s aftermath is that of an adult with their arm around a child, protective in the throes of death.  Thrash was the sole survivor on the premises.

Although the gruesome final snapshot of Jonestown is burned into the American popular imagination, the prelude to the massacre is not as well known.  Founded by the Reverend Jim Jones in the 1950s, Peoples Temple was a multiracial Pentecostal congregation with roots in Indiana. Over the course of two decades the church would establish operations in Ukiah, San Francisco and Los Angeles. In the late 1970s Jones relocated the bulk of the congregation to Guyana, ostensibly to avoid government persecution for its radical views. The Jonestown massacre has been dubbed one of the largest murder-suicides in world history.  About 75% of Peoples Temple members were African American, 20% were white and 5% were Asian, Latino and Native American.  The majority of its black members were women, while its core leadership was predominantly white.  As per the cultural cliché, black women like Thrash were “the backbone” of People’s Temple, the primary victims of Jonestown, and the population with the deepest investment in the philosophy, ethos and mission of the church.

It is troubling that of the scores of book length personal accounts, critical analyses and sociological appraisals on Peoples Temple and Jonestown only a few are by black women (the best of these have been compiled at the “Alternative Considerations of Jonestown and Peoples Temple” site). Thrash and Leslie Wagner–Wilson are currently the only two black women survivors to publish books on their experiences.  Wagner-Wilson managed to escape Jonestown before the massacre with several of her family members.  As early African American members of the church when it was based in Indiana, Thrash and her sister tithed 20% of their income to Peoples Temple.  Thousands of dollars in property sales, Social Security, disability, and welfare benefits from Temple members were funneled into the church’s empire.  Despite being elderly and infirm, Thrash and her sister followed Jones from Indiana to Ukiah, San Francisco and Guyana.  Eventually Thrash became disgruntled with the divide between Jones’ rhetoric of racial equality and the white-people-first reality of church leadership but stayed put nonetheless.

Unpacking why so many black women died in Jonestown requires taking a critical look back at the racial underbelly of the Jonestown age.  It demands confronting hard truths about the dangerously gendered seductions of organized religion; especially given the global appeal 24/7 prayer movements and charismatic Pentecostalism have for women of color.

According to a 2012 Kaiser Foundation/Washington Post poll, black women are among the most steadfastly religious groups in the nation.  Only 2% said that being religious was not important to them at all (compared to 15% of white men), while 74% said that it was extremely important. Numerous surveys have touted the decline of American religiosity within the past decade. Yet, in an era of black economic depression, the need to be devout or churched up has not diminished for most African American women, despite the patriarchal, heterosexist orientation of the Black Church.

The widening wealth gap between blacks, whites and Latinos, coupled with the downward mobility of the black middle class, only amplifies the role of religion in black life.  Because charismatic faith movements feed on socioeconomic and political turbulence black religiosity is a thriving enterprise (as the breakout popularity of the new reality show Preachers of L.A. attests).  Peoples Temple rose to prominence in San Francisco during the turbulence of the post-civil rights, post-Black Power, post-Vietnam War era.  A self-proclaimed Marxist who fetishized black liberation struggle, Jim Jones actively courted the support and approval of the Bay Area liberal political establishment.  He skillfully mined the language of social justice, racial equality and anti-sexism in an era in which disillusion with the possibility of freedom from institutional oppression ran high.  He touted a liberation theology ethos (which he dubbed apostolic socialism) which married the “best” parts of the Christian social gospel with a vision of communalism and egalitarianism that more closely aligned with his inherent atheism.  Initially this rhetoric was actualized in an array of social welfare programs (such as free community meals, housing and health care) for church members.  It would be perverted through a systematic pattern of paranoia, abuse and persecution fueled by Jones and his inner circle.

Numerous accounts document how Temple members were party to and complicit in the public abuse, harassment, humiliation and sexual exploitation of their fellow parishioners.  Some members vigorously defended these practices up until the final act of murder-suicide, an event that had been promoted and rehearsed several times.  When the fated day came, Christine Miller, a fifty-something year old African American woman, was the sole objector caught on the so-called death tape, challenging Jones’ death decree until she was shouted down by zealous African American Temple members.  It is difficult to listen to or read these accounts without feeling the deep complicity of the community.  As many survivors have stated, Peoples Temple was initially an uplifting experience because of its ability to unify members around the common cause of social justice.  Its message of racial harmony and cultural diversity resonated with white counterculture folk, aging white radicals, progressive Christians looking for an alternative to the insularity of mainstream traditions like the Black Church and people of color from all walks of life.  However this veneer of equality hid a pernicious race and gender hierarchy in which the Temple’s vaunted inner circle was comprised of white women who were fatally loyal to Jones and his perverse will.  This tight knit cadre of white women was Jones’ brain trust, becoming his psychological henchwomen and enforcers.  The white Peoples Temple inner circle handled Temple funds, intimidated traitors and potential defectors and seduced VIPs out of political expediency.  To paraphrase San Diego State University professor Rebecca Moore—whose sisters Carolyn Layton and Annie Moore were two of Jones’ main lover/lieutenants—if any Peoples Temple constituency had the power to stop the Jonestown massacre these women did, but they did not.  In eschewing the bourgeois trappings of “proper” white femininity they wound up reinforcing a white supremacist social order that some African American members likened to that of the plantation, complete with Miss Ann wielding the whip.

In many regards, Jones became the charismatic white Jesus father figure that so many black women are besotted with today.  In her book, Thrash speaks of how Jones’ straying from the Bible was the fatal flaw of Peoples Temple.  If he’d only been more of a God-fearing Christian, instead of a false prophet who set himself up as God, then surely the massacre wouldn’t have happened.  She believed she was spared from the massacre because “guardian angels” were protecting her and “God was in the plan”.  But in the business of organized religion, simply substituting one false prophet or God for another is a “devil’s bargain”.  Where was God for the 918 dead, some of the devoutest women on the planet?

Sikivu Hutchinson is the author of Godless Americana: Race and Religious Rebels and Moral Combat: Black Atheists, Gender Politics, and the Values Wars. She is currently working on a novel based on the Jonestown massacre entitled White Nights.

  • Pingback: ‘A self-proclaimed Marxist who fetishized black liberation struggle…’

  • nicthommi

    Not old enough to remember Jonestown but for some reason, it was a bit of history that my mom told me about. I think it was because there were so many black victims. I’m not devout at all and rarely attend church, and i feel as someone who isn’t agnostic or atheist, but is a but unusual as a black woman(although I often think that to other black woman, not going to church is the same as being an atheist), b/c most of my friends make having a church home and being part of a church “family” to be a big priority for them. I don’t necessarily think I need a mediator to have my own relationship with God.

    But this article reminds of me how troubled I am that black woman accept a number of abuses in the name of being “good Christians”, both from the men in their lives and from the pastor, who I think is vaunted so much in black American culture, and while nothing as shocking as Jonestown comes to mind, I have read stories of black pastors infecting female parishioners with HIV (a church leader who was having relationships with multiple women in his church), or chastising black women for “misplaced priorities”, and in general, I find I hear black women made excuses for being treated as less than equal partners in relationships and marriages in the name of “religion” or “praying” about decisions that they should make using rational and logical thought. I’m also bothered by the misogynistic advice I feel some black women receive when they approach their pastors as the ultimate authority of personal matters.

    I was not raised as part of a religion that has a large black population or a member of a “black” church but I was exposed to it b/c of its cultural relevancy and I was always bothered by how much of the message had misogynistic undertones…criticism levied at black women that does not address men as being culpable in any problems that exist in the black community at all. So I have trouble supporting institutions that are complicit in and in fact enable abuses against black women, and it’s hard to separate that image in my mind.

    And don’t even get me start on attitudes regarding mental health treatment..

  • yazikus

    Wow Sikivu, powerfully written (Do I say that everytime I comment on something you’ve written?) I had a roommate years ago whose mother had escaped Jonestown to attend the deposition, and had looked it up after she told me that. When I read about what the early message was, I thought, no wonder people went, I probably would have signed up in a hot minute too. Thanks for shifting the frame on this, so we might look at it in such a way that we can change to avoid this ever happening again.

    • Sikivu

      Absolutely Yazikus — that is one of the reasons why I was motivated to write this and delve more deeply into black women’s complicity/victimization. So many contemporary parallels with the scourge of hyper-religious Christian megachurch idolatry

  • Wong Chia Chi

    So many feelings about this. This whole incident makes me so sad. People really want something to believe in and every person I’ve known who claims to represent religion that I’ve known in my life tends to be narcissistic and self aggrandising. I wish people didn’t believe these evil messengers.

    • nicthommi

      I agree…it is weird to me how putting on a collar makes people listen to things that go against their own self-interests and suggest that they tolerate being disrespected and abused.

      • Wong Chia Chi

        They don’t even have to have authority I find. In every situation, especially in a group these kinds of people get tolerated and I don’t really understand why. They don’t even have to be charming or particularly intelligent from what I’ve seen they can be the opposite of that and still be treated like royalty. It’s something about our society that tolerates/encourages/rewards this kind of behaviour. Because these kinds of people keep “winning” nobody seems to condemn what they do until things like this happen and by then it’s too late. Or they’re like resigned to it and they think it’s okay. At least that’s what I’ve seen with my generation at work/school. I’ve seen it more an more lately so it really resonates with me.

        • nicthommi

          Well, I definitley think that black women raised in black church sometimes get trained to tolerate abuse in the name of being a good follower. I’m black, but was raised in a Christiian denomiation with few black members. When I did attend black church, the attitudes towards women in those settings was a stark contrast to the role women play in my own denomination (which isn’t even one of the more liberal ones, but is one that doesn’t have issues with women as pastors). I mean, hearing people get angry at the idea of women in the pulpit and hearing other women and men endorse that thinking, or listening to ministers who encouraged women to submit to their husbands (and this plays out in black women tolerating and remaining in very unhealthy relationships, accepting infidelity and abuse, all in the name of being a good Christian woman). Or the attacks on the problems in the black community as being the fault of black women, or the castigation of black women for their choices while men are never called to the carpet. I once heard a pastor attack women for seeking divorces, yet I was seated behind a row of unmarried teenage mothers, and I would have thought speaking to men about how making lots of babies doens’t make you a man would have been more appropriate.
          So many obvious snake oil salesmen, even in “legitimate” religions, and so many people passing money(that they don’t have…I dislike how black churches with lower income members will still make their pastors rich) to men who use it to bankroll lifestyles that most rappers and professional athletes would envy.

          • Wong Chia Chi

            Oh I definitely agree with you there. Religious environments create a kind of group think where people ignore their better judgement for favor of “fitting in”. I’m black also but I can’t really speak on it I just noticed that many jobs/corporations tend to be like this also although to a less severe degree.