Dear Lena Dunham: I Exist
Though perhaps with a Black homeless man catcalling Hannah on the street, an Asian girl with about fifteen seconds of dialogue taking the job Hannah believes she’s entitled to, mentioning Nigeria as a segue to a joke about the evils of working at McDonalds, and her boyfriend telling her emphatically not be a slave to anyone, Dunham thought she’d incorporated a perfunctory amount of color into the New York she’s created for Hannah. So far to be non-white in Hannah’s New York is something to subconsciously vilified.
Consider these statements from Dunham’s HuffPo interview and Nussbaum’s piece in NY Magazine:
“Our generation is not just white girls. It’s guys. Women of color. Gay people. The idea that I could speak for everyone is so absurd. But what is nice is if I could speak for me and it’s resonant for people, then that’s about as much as I could hope for.” – Dunham
“Still, like SATC, Dunham’s show takes as its subject women who are quite demographically specific—cosseted white New Yorkers from educated backgrounds—then mines their lives for the universal.”- Nussbaum
But why are the only lives that can be mined for “universal experiences” the lives of white women? Dunham’s statement on the other hand, makes me question her overall skill as a writer (you can’t write about anyone besides yourself?), while also implying that there’s some special way to write people who aren’t straight and white. That the problems she presents in Girls couldn’t be happen to anyone who doesn’t look like her.
Perhaps it would help if she were to hire a staff writer of color or a consultant for her writing team, because I’m not sure her staff gets it, either:

Courtesy: Girls staff writer Lesley Arfin, via Twitter
I can’t say if being mandated to take classes focused on a non-white experience have fixed Girls and Lena Dunham. I also wouldn’t argue that that’s the only thing wrong with her attitude (Dunham says in her profile in The New Yorker, “Let’s call a spade a spade—a lot of times when you are a vegetarian it is a just not very effective eating disorder.”) or with the show, but I genuinely wonder if it would have helped. Or at least given her some perspective if she really had spent her time growing up in NYC completely oblivious to the brown folk walking past her on a daily basis.
I refuse to believe that you can sit through a Spike Lee film, study his work, read his screenplays, and then believe that this is the proper way to cast a show set in Brooklyn– even the wealthier areas of Brooklyn (I can’t wait to see what Blue Ivy Carter’s circle of high school friends looks like). Media studies programs–especially my alma mater’s–should take note of the work their students produce and the attitudes they display and seriously consider if that’s the legacy they’ve intended to release into the world.
Lena Dunham and I may have a bit in common, but regardless of what Emily Nussbaum says, I do not consider Girls to be For Us or By Us. Nussbaum’s “Us” and Dunham’s show eliminate not only the other two-thirds of Brooklyn that exist, the reality of a minority-majority NYC population, but also the reality that my friends and I are currently living. Once again, we’ve been erased from a narrative.
Is a change in curriculum going to fix that overnight? No, not overnight. But I’d feel a whole lot better knowing that those who are going to speak for and represent the “Millennial Generation” (as NY Magazine claims Girls does) have studied and learned something about people that don’t fit the show’s mold. Maybe that’s when erasure begins to fade.
Page 3 of 3 | Previous page
Pingback: HBO’s Girls: Black and White in the Media | Citizen of the Month
Pingback: Life is “Hard” for Rich White “Girls” | Modern Primate | The Manhood Manual
Pingback: Influence Film – movies news » What Are We Mad At Lena Dunham About Today?
Pingback: Weekly Feminist Reader
Pingback: ‘Girls’ Talk « One Unique Token
Pingback: Girl talk: live chat about HBO’s Girls | Old News
Pingback: What I’m Reading… « Feminist Conscience
Pingback: A Black Man's Take on HBO's "Girls" | Political News and Opinion from a Multicultural Point of View
Pingback: Black Man’s Take on HBO’s “Girls” « Dr. Jason Johnson
Pingback: “Guys”. « Kissing Contest
Pingback: Girls HBO: Arfin Gate & Asian Female Characters
Pingback: Why the “QueenS” Video is as Beautiful as it is Important | Clutch Magazine
Pingback: buzz on the internet this week syncs up to class discussion today – racism + tv | J412: TV Criticism
Pingback: Meet the new boss | joelfrominwood
Pingback: まだ分からへん
Pingback: HBO’s Girls: The Story of a Multi-Coloured Girl | Discrimination | 8Asians.com
Pingback: Lena Dunham Addresses The Racial Backlash To Girls
Pingback: On Rosario Dawson as Dolores Huerta | The Daily Chicana
Pingback: Cynthia Hawkins | The Trouble with Girls | The Nervous Breakdown
Pingback: Flavorwire » Revisiting Lena Dunham, ‘Girls,’ and Race
Pingback: ‘Girls’ Talk | ArtSTALK - Dangerously obsessed with pop culture
Pingback: Racialicious Crush Of The Week: Azealia Banks | Racialicious - the intersection of race and pop culture