We Are Not Invisible: 5 African Women Respond To The Kony 2012 Campaign

Courtesy: The Australian

By Guest Contributor Spectra, cross-posted from Spectra Speaks

The Stop Kony 2012 campaign launched recently by Invisible Children to raise awareness of the issues of child soldiers in Uganda in which they propose what they believe to be the ultimate solution — arrest Kony, the LRA rebel leader responsible for over 30,000 child abductions — was met with overnight “success” (i.e. over 50 million views on YouTube) and then heightened controversy; there are critiques that suggest the video promotes a white saviorist approach to humanitarianism, others that applaud the effort but challenge the film’s inaccuracies, and many more that call for the inclusion of more African voices in Invisible Children’s advocacy efforts.

Almost overnight, the web was flooded with so much commentary from western media on the erasure of African voices that it became challenging for me to even locate perspectives from fellow Africans; ironically, African voices weren’t initially just being drowned out by the success of IC’s viral campaign, but by western voices sharing their own take. Fortunately, African voices stepped up to the  plate, offering a wide range of perspectives; you can find a compilation of African responses to the campaign here, and a more general roundup of the Kony2012 issue here.

Nevertheless, I’m (as always) acutely aware of the amplification of male voices on the Kony 2012 campaign. Hence — and in the spirit of women’s history month — I’d like to highlight African women’s voices. The 5 women below aren’t just adding to the conversation, but inspiring critical thinking about how we can be more conscious about the media we consume, more humble in our efforts to provide support to fellow global citizens, and mindful of the gift social media has given us. Africans now have the power to combat harmful narratives about Africa simply by telling our own.

So, here they are: 5 responses from African women to Kony 2012, and westerners seeking to support Africa, ethically and responsibly, now and in the future.

1) Solome Lemma
Involve African Leadership, Work with Organizations on the Ground

Soon after I heard about the Kony 2012 campaign (and watched the video), I read “You Do NOT Have My Vote” written by Solome Lemma under her Innovate Africa Tumblr.

Lemma is also the Co-Founder of HornLight, a platform to share diverse, complex, and nuanced narratives on the Horn of Africa. In this post, she stresses the need for African leadership:

… when your work and consequence affect a different group of people than your target audience, you must make it a priority to engage the voices of the affected population in a real and meaningful way, in places and spaces where programs are designed, strategies dissected, and decisions made.

Read the full post at innovateafrica.tumblr.com, and follow @InnovateAfrica on Twitter.

2) Rosebell Kagumire
Respect Africa’s Agency, Don’t Paint Us As Voiceless

While the cyberspace heated up with written critique upon written critique, Rosebell Kagumire, a Ugandan blogger and journalist that covered the LRA several years ago, decided to post a video summarizing her thoughts.

In this video, she passionately asserts the danger of a single story to dehumanize a people:

How you tell the stories of Africans is much more important that what the story is; because if you are showing me as voiceless, as hopeless [then] you have no space telling my story. You shouldn’t be telling my story if you don’t believe that I also have the power to change what is going on.

Kagumire also stresses the importance of including African leadership, as well as engaging other political players such as the Ugandan government and other African countries before attempting to implement any solutions.

Visit Kagumire’s blog here, and follow @RosebellK

3) Betty Oyella Bigombe
Historical Context is Necessary for Any Future Solutions

Although Betty isn’t currently directly involved with peace efforts for the LRA, nor has she written a formal response to the Invisible Children campaign, she has been quoted and cited several times as a notable Ugandan peace-seeking activist the Kony2012 video erases by suggesting that there’s been limited attention called to the issue. Not only was Betty previously tasked with convincing the Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA) guerilla rebels –negotiating with Kony himself over 10 years ago — to lay down their arms, following the failure of military efforts to defeat the rebels, her shared experiences working from all sides of the conflict provide counter to IC’s claim that there are just good guys and bad guys. From CSMonitor.com:

Bigombe has seen the LRA’s brutality first-hand. In 1995, when she was a government minister, she was the first outsider on the scene of one of its bloodiest massacres. Rebels attacked a town and captured about 220 men, women, and children. The villagers were marched several miles to a riverbank and all methodically executed.

Yet sometimes Bigombe sees glimmers of humanity, too. Once, one LRA commander grew pensive during a conversation. He wondered how his fellow northerners would perceive him after all the terrible things the LRA has done. He asked plaintively, “Can I ever go home again?”

Read her full story herewatch a video of Bigombe speaking here, as well as this recent interview with her on Enough Project.

4) Dayo Olopade
Support the Mundane March Towards Progress, Not Just Internet Sensationalism

As a fellow Nigerian, I was thrilled to see Olopade mentioned in this list of Africans commenting on the Kony 2012 campaign. She recently wrote an opinion piece for the New York Times about the gap between what the the Kony 2012 campaign suggests as a solution and what Ugandan people dealing with the daily impact of this conflict actually need. Here is an excerpt (edited for brevity):

In Kampala last month, I met Hadijah Nankanja, the local director of Women of Kireka, a collective of women touched by Kony’s marauding violence… Hadijah and I tried to come up with a way forward. Food production? Tailoring? Hair salons? And so forth. We didn’t come up with a concrete plan, but opening a small restaurant seemed to be the front-running proposition. Our informal brainstorming session took about the same time as does watching “Kony 2012.” I dare suggest that time spent marshaling such reserves of imagination, communion and capital to support jobs for displaced victims is far more helpful than this sort of advocacy. The kinds of problems Hadijah is trying to understand and solve are less sexy than the horror stories trailing behind Kony. But they are the nut worth cracking. The mundane march of progress in poor countries is what ‘awareness’ campaigns often miss. And when, as in this case, success is determined by action from outside the region, cries of a new imperialism should be taken seriously. Few international NGOs working in Africa define success properly — as putting themselves out of business. Invisible Children seems no better.”

Olopade is a Nigerian-American journalist covering global politics and development policy. She is writing a book about innovation in Africa. You can follow her at @madayo on Twitter.

5) Semhar Araia
Use Media to Amplify African Voices, Not Just Your Own

Araia is the founder of the Diaspora African Women’s Network (DAWN), which “develops and supports talented women and girls of the African diaspora.”

In her opinion piece at the Christian Science Monitor, “Learn to Respect Africans,” Araia refocuses the conversation on the impact of media on young people thirsty for information:

… young people’s minds are open and hungry. They should be inspired by knowing Africa is empowered, saving itself, and working with partners to remove Kony. That is the real story. Invisible Children must be willing to take their followers on a journey through the Africa that Africans know. They must be willing to inspire – but also to manage – their followers’ expectations. They must be willing to use their media to amplify African voices, not simply their own.

It’s no wonder she started the twitter hashtag, #WhatILoveAboutAfrica. In response to negative portrayals of the continent put forth by western media, and most recently, through the Kony 2012 campaign, Araia commands that we do more than just critique visions of Africa, but create them ourselves. Follow @Semhar and @DawnInc on Twitter.

So, that’s the word–African women have spoken. If you’re interested in supporting the people of Northern Uganda, but would like an alternative to donating to Invisible Children, consider supporting organizations such as Hope North Uganda and The Women of Kireka. In fact, Invisible Children has recently shared a list of other organizations working on the this issue in Uganda.

Finally, if you’re itching for a new video to share, share this one, make this one go viral. Viva Africa.

  • Pingback: Life is complicated. Kony 2012. « Angel and Tiggs

  • Pingback: Sunday Scan | This Might Be True

  • Pingback: Notable Links: 3-16/12 « BROTHA WOLF

  • Enki

    The ruthless exploitation of African’s by whites continues circa Kony2012. It is a grotesquely racists and profoundly cynical ploy by a wealthy, white NGO whose interests and agenda have little to do with the real needs of Africans, much less the doing away with the larger geopolitical context that empower personalities like Kony – EVERYWHERE.  Arresting him will do little to change anything on the ground in Africa except re-invigorate the self-serving narratives of white male supremacy and the West’s techno-fetishism vis-a-vis social media, blah, blah, blah. It is all very much about the status quo of how whites see themselves, particularly american middle class whites. 

    http://www.wsws.org/articles/2012/mar2012/kony-m14.shtmlhttp://thesituationist.wordpress.com/2012/03/10/looking-for-the-evil-actor-reposted/ 

    Kony is a weak and meaningless puppet for somebody, a strawman target.  Never mind that America has its own human rights criminals like Kissinger, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Albright  who systematically murdered near a million human beings in Iraq BEFORE the war – mostly children. Now President Obama who has authorized the murder of American citizens without due process and routinely approves the slaughter innocents under the ruse of the ‘War on Terror’.  Never mind the corporate pyschopaths who ravage the planet and immiserate billions of human beings under the guise of market utopia and its narrative of  ‘no alternative’. 

    No, we can not oppose the real social criminals, the ones that run the planet, award our diplomas, sign our checks, and command our institutions.  That would be unthinkable.  Instead, we crave our two minutes of hate and then move on to the next show. 

  • Pingback: likeable links « Angela In Asia

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Cocojams-Jambalayah/100000590546331 Cocojams Jambalayah

    A facebook friend of mine shared this link to what I consider a very insightful post and interesting comment thread on the “poor Africa/Kony meme.  http://www.xojane.com/issues/why-whole-poor-africa-thing-isnt-cool Bassey Ikpi 3/15/2012
                          Here’s an excerpt of the poster’s response to a comment from a reader:”…I was speaking to the fact that the Stop Kony meme is flawed and only serves to invalidate the work that is already going on. I support many organizations that do work in these places however, it is about supporting the infrastructure and putting in place something that works long after people have stopped using the hashtag. Neither the t-shirts nor the bracelets that are being sold by Stop Kony are even being made in Uganda. This is charity propaganda that obfuscates the point in order to push a well-meaning agenda. My point is that “well-meaning” isn’t enough to ignore the problems with the organization…
    I’m all for humanitarian efforts and I would never invalidate the people who were rightfully moved by the film and the statements surrounding it. Compassion and empathy should be celebrated but not at the cost of truth.
    AlsoHere are some Ugandans who can speak for themselves: http://www.theglobeandmail.com
    http://www.boingboing.net/2012
    And then there’s this:http://newsone.com/world/afish… “

  • Jay

    “Support the Mundane March Towards Progress, Not Just Internet Sensationalism”I think I have a new motto.It’s exhausting to watch people seize on the latest ‘outrage’ they don’t bother to investigate or understand, only to drop it in a few days or weeks when the next ‘outrage’ pops up. Do they really think this helps anyone, anywhere?

  • Pingback: Reflections on Kony | EcoHustler

  • http://vuga.wordpress.com/ YoungAfrican

    As a Ugandan woman, I very much appreciate this

  • http://DeadAmericanDream.blogspot.com AngryBroomstick

    Ya know what? Upon the first sight of seeing the Kony 2012 video on Tumblr (it had over 400,000 reblogs alone), I immediately thought “well if Kony is a bad man, what about the others working with him? shouldn’t they also be arrested and be held accountable for crimes against humanity”? I am amazed that to this day, people still single out ONE PERSON being responsible for atrocities or war crimes. One person cannot do all that alone. It takes a GROUP OF PEOPLE to make it happen. I hate to invoke Godwin’s Law, but Hitler didn’t act alone. He had aquaintances, he had followers, he had an entire political party behind him. Arresting Kony alone wouldn’t solve anything.

    Also, this is frustrating — a group of WHITE MEN make a video about Uganda and Kony, it goes VIRAL and spreads like wildfire on the Internet…  and a group of intelligent African women w/ years of constant reporting on Kony, continue to be ignored by the media. Why does this keep happening all the DAMN TIME?

    and… “Invisible Children” is an offensive title, implying that nobody else has noticed or spoken up about what children in the LRA have experienced. *rolls eyes*

  • Kat

    This post makes me uncomfortable: I would not seek a Mexican opinion on a US issue or a Canadian one on a US issue. So why are Nigerians and expat Ethiopians here allowed to speak for Ugandans? The countries do not even share borders. (And in the case of the expats- well, they are not even on the same continent) While well intended, this seems to perpetuate the “Africa-as-a-state” narrative.

    • Anonymous

      I get where you’re coming from with that, and you’re right–it doesn’t make sense to ask Nigerians and Ethiopians to speak for Ugandans. But I don’t see any of these pieces as hijacking anyone’s voice. These women are leveling their own informed criticisms of the campaign–like the Grant Oysten and Michael Wilkerson pieces profiled earlier this week–and they aren’t claiming to represent anyone but themselves. Since colonial and neocolonial narratives, American representations of African countries as indistinguishable and in need of white saviors, and issues surrounding irresponsible international aid are relevant to other African countries, I do think these voices should be privileged in the conversation.

    • Vintage3000

      Are you more comfortable with White westerners speaking for Ugandans?

      Also, I don’t get a sense of Ugandans being substituted for other Africans in this piece.  Kagumire is Ugandan, Bigombe has seen Kony’s aftermath for herself, and the other women are basically stating it’s crucial for African voices to be heard regarding African issues.  Should they not speak about how the entire continent is regarded by global media, just because they are not from Uganda? IMO that would indicate a lack of cohesiveness among Africans in general, which would be dangerous.

    • Vintage3000

      Are you more comfortable with White westerners speaking for Ugandans?

      Also, I don’t get a sense of Ugandans being substituted for other Africans in this piece.  Kagumire is Ugandan, Bigombe has seen Kony’s aftermath for herself, and the other women are basically stating it’s crucial for African voices to be heard regarding African issues.  Should they not speak about how the entire continent is regarded by global media, just because they are not from Uganda? IMO that would indicate a lack of cohesiveness among Africans in general, which would be dangerous.

  • Keith

    Neo colonializm on the continent of Africa is in full effect.

  • AA11

    I have heard such similar stories from Ugandan government officials and individuals at IC events asking for help and support. So many other organizations have been involved, and one of the biggest projects has been rehabilitation.