Ultimate Spider-Man Is Better Than Marvel’s Advertising Gives It Credit For

By Arturo R. García

In promoting the new Ultimate Spider-Man comic, which features a black Latino protagonist in Miles Morales, Marvel pulled out the kind of pull-quote driven advert you’d expect for a high-profile launch.

Unfortunately, the ad short-changes what proves to be a compelling, if not particularly exciting, story.

As seen above, the ad uses the first sentence in this story from ComicsBeat, which opens, “All of you folks who have been crying about diversity in comics had better be all over this!”

While the rest of the story is played straight, for Marvel to validate such blatant Othering of progressive comics fans – characterizing calls for diversity as “crying;” the Tropic Thunder-esque use of “you folks,” and the ransom-note language (“you had better be all over this!”) – is a questionable choice. Particularly since The Beat’s Editor-In-Chief, Heidi McDonald, has written more sensibly about Miles in other posts:

That panel of Miles demasking was everywhere yesterday. And the more I saw it, the more I loved it. It’s iconic (I wish the dialog were a little more iconic but so be it.) It’s a beautiful drawing full of character that draws me in. It reminds me a little of Velazquez’s portrait of Juan de Pareja, which is surely too high praise as that painting is one of the greatest of all times, but they share that sense of humanity which informs the best art.

Moving on to the story itself, McDonald’s critique of the artwork still holds up in USM #1. The tandem of Sara Pichelli (pencils) and Justin Ponsor (colors) shines best in the story’s city settings. Their Brooklyn looks lived in, and authentically, refreshingly diverse. This should be the norm by now, of course, but … well, you know. Comics.

Pichelli and Ponsor’s art also elevates writer Brian Michael Bendis’ riskiest creative choice: positioning Miles’ background as far away as possible from that of his predecessor, Peter Parker.

SPOILERS AHEAD

Set before Miles’ first appearance in Ultimate Fallout #4, Bendis spends USM #1 showing us how Miles got his powers, in an accident not unlike the one that granted Peter his abilities, and introducing us to his family. While it’s never said outright, it’s strongly suggested that Miles’ parents are having trouble making ends meet, a feeling that comes out most heavily in a sequence where the Morales clan attends the lottery for entry into a charter school.

According to former Marvel EIC Joe Quesada, the lottery scene was inspired by the documentary Waiting For Superman, and it could have veered into Poverty Porn pretty easily, but a crucial piece of direction by Bendis, along with the artists’ work, saves it: as Miles’ mother tells him, “Oh, my God, you have a chance,” we cut to a close-up on Miles’ eyes, then to two separate shots of kids whose names didn’t get called.

“It shouldn’t — all these other kids,” Miles says. “Should it be like this?” This show of empathy helps ground Miles for the readers at a crucial moment. He revisits these emotions later on, while visiting his uncle Aaron, something Miles’ dad doesn’t like – especially after Miles faints after his fateful accident, the consequences of which start to dawn on him as the story closes.

This kind of decompressed story – or “writing for the trade,” as fans often call it – might disappoint some of the new readers Bendis and Marvel want to hook with the new USM; after all, for a book selling for $3.99, it’s not unreasonable to suggest that after all the hype, it would have been nice to see Miles out “learning on the job” like we saw him doing in Ultimate Fallout.

But at this point, USM #1 accomplished what Bendis and company set out to do – show us a young hero worth getting invested in. The key now is to follow up: not just in the key details about Miles’ regular life (what are Miles’ parents’ names? What’s going on that has them so worried about their living situation?) but about the touches that will eventually make Miles his own Spider-Man; the tagline for the next issue, “Who Is Miles Morales?,” could hardly be more apropos.

  • PCS

    Isn’t it possible to have a critique of the system that elevates only a few, even as it elevates you? I know this interpretation is sort of undermined by the two shots of–lightskinned, if not white–kids, but I didn’t for sure read Miles as questioning the rightness of his own opportunity, but the rightness of the system.

  • Kendra

    I cannot stress enough how much I loved this book as a long time USM reader. I did a double take when not only was school lottery mentioned, but they spent most of the 20 pages on it. I’m definitely invested in Miles’ story, and I’m looking forward to watching him grow over (HOPEFULLY) the next decade. I hope that this pointed look at poverty/inequality in education doesn’t scare off the readers who bought the book because of the initial hype and excitement behind it.

    ( One Gripe: It was only 20 pages and still cost $4? Come on now, Marvel.)

  • http://robobtmcguiver.livejournal.com Carl

    Obviously, “All of you folks who have been crying about diversity in
    comics had better be all over this!” is the most absurd endorsement here
    (or ever), but what’s up with the rest of them — “I can’t blame Bendis
    for wanting to take a stab at something different”? “We have an African-American president, so
    why not an African-American Spider-Man, too?!”??!  “Best of luck”?  These read like they were fielded by Lou Dobbs.  Could Marvel try any harder to appear nastily ambivalent about this?

    …To say nothing of the fact that
    the media narrative surrounding it is the
    posterchild anti-”I Have a Dream” — the whole project is being judged not by
    the content of its character(s) but solely by the color of its hero’s skin.
    Seriously.  And for shame.