Dear SNL, It’s Time to Retire Virginiaca

by Special Correspondent Wendi Muse

“There’s mama drama at the mall!”

Do you ever just want to throw a very heavy object toward your television? I don’t even own a functioning television at present, using my laptop instead to get caught up on all the shows I miss (thanks Netflix, ABC, NBC, MTV, etc etc), but I still want to throw something very heavy and with a lot of force towards the LCD screen when Keenan Thompson comes onto the set of Saturday Night Live. Most of his depictions of black people, be they male or female, are racist and steeped in tired, overused stereotypes. When I see Keenan in drag, however, I become even more enraged because, considering the already heavy dark cloud of negative stereotypes of black women in film and on tv, I don’t think a black man needs to be adding to the fray simply because SNL hasn’t cast a black woman since, to the best of my recollection, Ellen Cleghorn (it’s sad that I even had to GUESS this!). Former cast member Maya Rudolph, who is of a multiracial background (she is the daughter of  the late singer Minnie Riperton and producer Richard Rudolph), often played black female characters, but in a way that I felt was often humorous without being offensive. Thompson, however, cannot seem to follow in Rudolph’s footsteps.

Thompson’s most grave offense toward black women to date, in my opinion, is his portrayal of Virginiaca, a poorly behaved, inappropriately sexual black woman who’s fallen into some money by marrying a wealthy white man. As a reference for those of you who cannot view the Hulu clips,  in the typical ”Shopping with Virginiaca” sketch, Virginiaca (Keenan Thompson,clad in an ill-fitting, tacky denim suit) takes her white stepdaughter (who now behaves in the same, stereotype-fulfilling way as Virginiaca, only it’s *reeeaaally funny* because the actress is white and “acting black”) to a retail store where they are both refused service as a result of their loud, outlandish behavior until Virginiaca mentions she is married to Cedrick Earlsworth Hasting, a white aluminum tubing magnate. Post name-dropping, Virginiaca and her daughter receive service, albeit at arm’s length. All of this is the framework for the climax of the mother-daughter pair booty dancing and Virginiaca sexually harassing the white, male store clerk.

For longtime readers of Racialicious, you may know that I’ve  mentioned my bone to pick with Keenan over Virginiaca before. The first time I saw Virginiaca was when Ellen Page was the special guest (the transcript which, by itself, is frightening enough, can be found here):

Then I saw it again (above) this weekend with Blake Lively of Gossip Girl and Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants fame.

Sadly, there are more Virginiaca sketches than I thought. A quick search on the internet brings forth gifts of Virginiaca sketches that include Scarlett Johansson, Jaime Pressly, and another with Justin Timberlake.

The fact that the skit continues without interruption. I recall that following my having written the previous assault on the Virginiaca sketch, a few readers wondered what could be done. One option? Voice your opinion. If the Virginiaca skit bothers you as much as it does me, please write NBC and give them a piece of your mind.

SNL Executive Staff (for your reference):

Executive producer: Lorne Michaels

Produced by: Steve Higgins

Director: Don Roy King

Supervising Producer: Ken Aymong

Producers: Marci Klein, Michael Shoemaker

Head Writer: Seth Meyers

Writers: Doug Abeles, James Anderson, Alex Baze, Jessica Conrad, James Downey, Steve Higgins, Colin Jost, Erik Kenward, Rob Klein, John Lutz, Seth Meyers, Lorne Michaels, John Mulaney, Paula Pell, Simon Rich, Marika Sawyer, Akiva Schaffer, John Solomon, Emily Spivey, Kent Sublette, Jorma Taccone, Bryan Tucker (*note that Thompson is NOT one of the writers)

Writing Supervised by: Paula Pell

NBC/Universial Executive Bios: http://www.nbcuni.com/About_NBC_Universal/Executive_Bios/

General Contact Form: http://www.nbc.com/contact/general/

Questions/Concerns email: feedback@nbcuni.com

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • NewsVine
  • Current
  • email
  • Print

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. Links of the Day (12/15/09) | my five year plan. on 15 Dec 2009 at 10:07 am

    [...] Wendy Muse to SNL: It’s Time to Retire Virginiaca [...]

  2. Stop it, Kenan « (how much were you) paid 2 coon? on 19 Dec 2009 at 3:49 pm

    [...] that man in Saturday Night Live’s Lorne Michaels, black actors get seriously coonerific. A repost from Racialicious on Kenan’s misogynistic and, ultimately, wholly unoriginal depiction of [...]

Comments

  1. Michele wrote:

    In 35 years SNL has had 3 1/2 black female cast members. Yvonne Hudson was on for 1 year, Danitra Vance on for 1 year, Ellen Cleghorn and Maya Rudolph. Ellen Cleghorn was marinalized for 4 years. The only black actress biracial Maya Rudolph was the only 1 with substantial air time. SNL has a very poor record for hiring and actually using poc actors.

  2. Eva wrote:

    Wow, this is offensive. I haven’t watched SNL in years but I don’t even get why anyone would NOT consider this offensive.

    Maybe they would take a complaint seriously from one of those Nielsen families.

  3. dogsofwar wrote:

    Goodbye incisive topical humor (Eddie Murphy’s “White Like Me” sketch from the 80’s), hello painfully unfunny stereotyping of the 21st Century (Virginiaca, Norbit, Martin Lawrence’s tired faux-fat schtick, et al).

    We had Richard Pryor and George Carlin, and this generation’s got Dane Cook, Jeff Dunham, and Carlos Mencia.

    I know there are great people out there doing comedy, just this post inspires the inner curmudgeonly ranter.

    Rather than taking chances and appealing to the mind, this latest SNL generation (the show had been on a decline since early 90’s IMO) is rocking the metaphorical equivalent of the popped collar.

    Man, I miss Chappelle’s show

  4. N wrote:

    I wish they would all retire this sort of thing. I have yet to forgive Jamie Foxx for Wanda or Halle Berry for BAPS. I’ll add this to my list and DEFINITELY complain.

  5. Queen B wrote:

    I can’t tell you how tired I am of seeing black woman being portrayed by black men in such an offensive manner. I do not why these depictions are funny.
    What is funny about a black man dressing up an overweight black woman? Martin Lawrence, Eddie Murphy and Tyle Perry have made millions off of this tired trope.

    I remember watching Oprah one day and Dave Chapelle was on and he recounted a story about how he was on a movie stet one day and of the producers or writers approached him and suggested he appear in drag/fat suit as a woman because I’m sure it would be perceived as very funy.
    I got the distinct impression that the person who made the suggestion was white. Chapelle did not follow in Murphy’s steps but it got me thinking about whose idea is it really to have black men appear as overweight black women.

    How many of SNL’s writers are black ? How many black people occupy positions of authority?

    What really bothers me as a black woman is that these kind of representations send a message that black women are not really women; they are not feminine but masculine so much so that any black man can portray them.

    I also think it is interesting that these caricatures are always fat or overweight and very loud or obnoxious. What kind of message is Hollywood sending: black + overweight+boisterous = entertainment for the white masses.

  6. Deaf Indian Muslim Anarchist wrote:

    I am also tired of how SNL (and the media in general) portrays black women– as some kind of a joke for everyone to point and laugh at. Har har har!

    Anyway, SNL stopped being funny long time ago and needs to just be cancelled already.

  7. Asianlawyer wrote:

    SNL is the wonder bread of sketch comedy. Bland, flavorless, unhealthy, and all white. Contrast this with the recently and regrettably canceled MadTV. The latter was much more edgy and risky when it came to doing comedy, especially racial comedy. However it had a relatively diverse cast and it was great at poking fun of societal absurdities, especially racial ones. Meanwhile SNL goes out of its way to not offend the PC elite consensus by not taking big risks or being purposefully offensive. But its racial cluelessness and all white cast (with the sprinkling of token minorities) is much more offensive that the most racially charged MadTV sketch.

  8. PPR_Scribe wrote:

    Man, I miss Chappelle’s show

    As much as I was a fan, he did not do much better than SNL does w/Black women, IMO.

  9. mieko wrote:

    Hah. I looked up the Eddie Murphy sketch on hulu, and at the end NBC’s logo came on with it’s new slogan: More colorful. How ironic!

  10. Tim wrote:

    SNL, back when the show was at all funny, actually did a better job at poking fun at racism and racial issues.

    My favorite, as a white reggae fan and student of Jamaican culture, was Eddie Murphy at the VFW hall…”kill the white people (but buy my record first)”

  11. shemari wrote:

    Not only was this offensive, it was seriously unfunny.

    SNL in general has been comedy free for quite some time anyway.

  12. Val wrote:

    @Queen B

    “What kind of message is Hollywood sending: black + overweight+boisterous = entertainment for the white masses.”

    I don’t know what kind of message they are trying to send but there are certainly a lot of Black actresses willing to be that stereotype who seem to get more than their share of work; Sherri Shepard, Monique, Niecy Nash, etc.

  13. R. Prince wrote:

    I just emailed NBC about this sketch and “Virginica” in general but I have a feeling I won’t be getting a response…. ever.

    @Val. Amen. I was watching an episode of Everybody Loves Raymond last night and Sherri Shepard’s character was willing to play the stereotypical angry/mean black woman… it didn’t help that her character was also a police officer which conveys authority and authority, as sexist as it is, still conveys masculinity so she was the big mean black police lady yelling at poor Raymond and shoving suspects around… I was just staring at the t.v. thinking, wow, it’s like to write a script where a black woman is kind or positive seems impossible… how hard could it have been to make her nice, just nice??! no they had to play up the stereotype for laughs because what else are black women good for besides a good laugh, snap her fingers, roll her neck, “oh no you didn’t” *guffawing ensues*.. they’re not really women, didn’t you know? they can’t be soft or kind for one minute! ugh! so sick of it…

  14. R. Prince wrote:

    oops, I also forgot to add another point which was Sherri Sheperd probably played that role b/c like I was thinking, what are black women good for on t.v. besides a good laugh… she may see this too and it could’ve bothered her but parts must be few and far between for women like her in hollywood… I want to put all the blame on her but then again…….

  15. Bagelsan wrote:

    I also think it is interesting that these caricatures are always fat or overweight and very loud or obnoxious. What kind of message is Hollywood sending: black + overweight+boisterous = entertainment for the white masses.

    I wonder if, for the cross-dressing male actors at least, having the character be big and loud and obnoxious is a way to avoid looking “gay” or like they are taking femininity seriously at all. If they wore women’s clothes and played a female character without the fat suit and the hate it might actually look like they respected women or took a female part seriously — and we can’t have that! I mean, what if one of those dudes ended up looking pretty okay when cross-dressed without the exaggeration and stereotypes? On noes! That’s totally gay!

    Obviously this dilemma could be entirely avoided by those insecure men if they just wouldn’t *play* women (rather than playing them poorly and offensively.) But that would be respectful of women, and we already established that *that* would be entirely unacceptable!

  16. nakedthoughts wrote:

    why did I just watch that instead just acknowledging your point and trusting your analysis? but no, I had to see for myself. this is how curiosity killed the cat.

    one more comment to add to the chorus:

    a fat person is constantly eating, and/or thinking about food.

    anti womyn, racist, fat phobic

  17. Andrea wrote:

    Thank you for posting this (I’m sorry I missed the first one) but yeah, man…I kept wondering “am I the only one that doesn’t think this is funny?” I think Keenan does NOTHING for that show =( I remember at one point they had three black comedians on there, and they chose to leave Keenan on…why?

  18. SarahNicole wrote:

    We had Richard Pryor and George Carlin, and this generation’s got Dane Cook, Jeff Dunham, and Carlos Mencia.

    I know there are great people out there doing comedy, just this post inspires the inner curmudgeonly ranter.

    While I join you in curmudgeonliness, I must just say: Wanda Sykes; Margaret Cho.

    I haven’t watched SNL in I don’t even know how long…

  19. yolanda wrote:

    i’m glad racialicious wrote an article about the trainwreck that is “Virginiaca.” the most recent one–in the blake lively episode–was horrific, the audience barely laughed at all. my friend and i watched it in her dorm room with a blank, confused expression on our faces and when it was finally (and painfully) over i said, “well…that was offensive” and she agreed.

  20. Wendi Muse wrote:

    hey yolanda,

    i wrote about this before back in the day (link above in the article), so it’s sad that this storyline/sketch continues. please write nbc to express your sentiments. encourage your friend to as well!

    ~Wendi

  21. AMarie wrote:

    I can’t remember ever watching SNL… I had no idea Keenan was dressing in drag and defaming Black women. Loud, large an brashly sexual… yup, there’s your stereotrypical Black woman.

    This was offensive and unfunny.

    Black actors need to step back and allow Black actresses to play more nuanced and complex characters instead of 1-dimensional caricatures. And the networks that perpetuate this mess? I’ll be sending them my regards shortly.

    @Bagelsan

    You have a point about masculinity and the appearance of being gay with regards to Black men in drag. I never thought of it that way… I just thought it was offensive that men could dress as women and call it entertainment.

  22. Westerly wrote:

    “I mean, what if one of those dudes ended up looking pretty okay when cross-dressed without the exaggeration and stereotypes? On noes! That’s totally gay.”

    Good point Bagelsan regarding drag-dressing. It *has* to be for laughs and it has to ridicule otherwise…

    I’m pretty wary about most comedy anyway (comedy is a political minefield and too often it is painfully unfunny or an excuse to be a right arse towards _______ [fill in the blank]

    But what I’ve learnt from watching American comedy is that Black women are ‘always’
    a.) Fat
    b.) Loud, garish and obnxious
    c.) domineering
    d.) Masculine and by extension ‘unattractive’.
    e.) Ridiculous and not worthy of an iota of respect.

    Hey, I could live with ALL of the above if I ever got to see any other alternative. I’m always curious as to who is watching this stuff anyway and who derives pleasure from it.

    Sure there are directors and writers in film and TV that are skillful and actually care about craft but from what I’ve seen far too many of them are crap at their jobs and utterly thoughtless, unoriginal and lazy at what they do, and you wonder on earth they got hired in the first place and why there is an insistence on such repetitive mediocrity?

  23. urban Suburbinite wrote:

    “@Bagelsan
    You have a point about masculinity and the appearance of being gay with regards to Black men in drag.”

    ITA. I think Tyler Perry is going through this now, with people questioning his sexuality based on how convincingly he plays Madea.

    I think we could take it a step further and agree not to watch SNL at all. It hasn’t been funny since 1991.

    Letter writing/emailing does little to affect anything as producers/production assistants just delete them. A better approach is to boycott the programming and the products of the sponsors. You’ve got to hit them in the pocket, because they don’t care about your feelings. If they did the skit would have never been aired.

    I’m not saying that you shouldn’t email, just that that alone is not enough.

  24. Wendi Muse wrote:

    hi urban suburbinite,
    the main reason i note to write emails to NBC about this is because while hurting their pockets helps, it’s much harder to do on a grand scale based solely on one skit. editors and writers of magazines, blogs, papers, and other forms of print, audio, and visual media DO take their fans’ thoughts seriously and often cater the content accordingly. not to mention the fact that this is being blogged about, and no one like negative press. this site and the work on it, in addition to reader feedback elsewhere, is more influential than you’d imagine. the more this story is shared around the blogosphere, the more people write, the better. getting say, 200 people to not watch snl won’t do *as* much in the short term because not all of those people will be participating in the nielson poll or necessarily purchasing from corporate sponsors of snl in the first place.

  25. urban Suburbinite wrote:

    Thanks Wendi.

    “…no one like negative press. this site and the work on it, in addition to reader feedback elsewhere, is more influential than you’d imagine. the more this story is shared around the blogosphere, the more people write, the better.”

    I hear what you are saying, and I agree with this 100%. I neglected to think of that aspect, and was focusing on just the email. Movements can definitely catch fire online.

    “it’s much harder to do on a grand scale based solely on one skit. ”

    I was referring to all of SNL in it’s current incarnation, more so than just the one skit. I should have clarified. The lack of people of color in front and behind the scenes. The near constant blackface and new yellowface. It’s all so disgusting.

    “editors and writers of magazines, blogs, papers, and other forms of print, audio, and visual media DO take their fans’ thoughts seriously and often cater the content accordingly.”

    I would qualify that by adding the word “some” at the beginning. Also are we really their fans? They seem to have a target demographic of white male aging fratboy types. SNL’s history has proven that they are not concerned with POC or women (at times), as a target audience.

  26. Wendi Muse wrote:

    hi urban suburbinite,

    you raise a good point about target demographics. with SNL, i find that it’s becoming increasingly more difficult to identity their target group because their humor is just…not well rounded. it’s become more and more slapstick style over the years and i agree that women, poc, and queer people are often the butt of every joke.

    i am with you in wondering who still watches it faithfully (if anyone) and why? could it simply be that we keep going back for more in hopes that it will improve?!

    btw, i hope that my reply to you wasn’t read as defensive. things in text form sometimes come across too strong or not strong enough, so i appreciate your having taken the time to reply with more clarity.

  27. LaKeshia Gibson wrote:

    To think I once liked Keenan and Ellen Page…..oh well, off to chuck “Juno” in the trash where it belongs.

  28. lee wrote:

    Not that it makes it any better, but at least keenan doesn’t need to wear a fat suit. *rolls eyes*

    I had the exact same thoughts the other week when I watched the SNL with Blake Lively and I saw the Virginiaca sketch. SNL has approximately ONE black cast member and approximately ZERO black writers. Not to mention that comedy shows are notorious for under-representing female writers. What right do they have to constantly make black women the butt of jokes?

    On a different note, I find it a little bit clever that different people always play Virginiaca’s step daughter.

  29. urban Suburbinite wrote:

    @ Wendi
    “btw, i hope that my reply to you wasn’t read as defensive.”

    Not at all. I just took it as open dialog/discussion. That’s what makes this site great.

  30. yassibassu wrote:

    I feel bad for keenan…they always give him this crap to do. It’s like watching the cleveland show, except keenan is black.

  31. Thom wrote:

    “I must just say: Wanda Sykes; Margaret Cho. ”

    Although, Wanda’s career has largely been “Sassy Black Woman Who Shakes Her Head And Makes Sassy Comments About White People.” Don’t get me wrong, I like Wanda, and I find her funny even in that type of Role… but she has notsteered clear of playing “black stereotypes” in her roles.

  32. P. wrote:

    Kenan Thompson started playing this character (under the name Ladisha) on Nickelodeon’s All That in 1998.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=09EsyR9iLvE

    Sadly, it probably helped him to land the job at SNL. While the writers may pen the material, Thompson still agrees to perform it.

    I think letters to him may be in order as well.