The next generation – and what women sometimes forget – on December 6th

By Special Correspondent Jessica Yee, originally published at CITIZENShift

Editor’s note: Yesterday, December 6th, was the National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women in Canada, in commemoration of the Montréal Massacre.  Jessica Yee wrote the following article to draw attention to the racialized nature of violence against women, among other things.

It’s December 6th 2009, and many people have been asking me what I’m thinking today. What do I think about this day where 20 years ago, a man walked into a Montreal engineering college and shot 14 women, specifically because they were women. Interestingly enough, I had to fight to have a female Aboriginal Elder open and be present at the event I’m speaking at today because the organizers “didn’t want to detract from the meaning of the day” by me asking her to say some words. It’s the 20th anniversary of the École Polytechnique shooting, and people keep asking me, so what do I think about that?

I’m thinking a lot of things in fact. Yes, I’m from the next generation of women who were too young to remember when the murders actually took place, but I suppose I belong to the current generation of women who identify themselves with feminist politics and have heard from the foremothers of this movement in Canada about the significance of remembering the day, and to never forget it. They say, “Women Won’t Forget” on December 6th. But as a young, sex working, multiracial, bisexual, two-spirited, Aboriginal woman, I think that sometimes, especially at these December 6th type events, women DO forget a few things:

Sometimes women forget that as Aboriginal women, we are five times more likely to die of violence than any other race of women in Canada, and that women have been going missing and being murdered in our communities by the thousands, for hundreds of years.

Women forget that while we show up to vigils and talk up a nice speech about some “poor prostitute” who died on the streets, we simultaneously judge, shun, and degrade current sex workers and speak against decriminalization – something that might actually help protect us.

Sometimes, women forget that same-sex violence should be taken as seriously as man to woman violence and that we really don’t talk about violence in the queer community as often as we could.

Women forget that Elder violence is very real and is happening, but also that a lot of it is committed against young women, who deserve the opportunity to speak for ourselves as youth, not be spoken for by yet another generation of first or second wave feminists that don’t want to give up their power yet.

And if you are reading this and thinking to yourself “well, I don’t forget that on December 6th” please, don’t expend your energy to get mad at me. Direct that passion towards reminding another woman now that you’ve read this, or someone else for that matter who is forgetting, or who just doesn’t know.

For the record, I refuse to have another argument with someone about what this day is “only” supposed to commemorate.

What about you?

Photo of poster made to honour the lives of missing or murdered aboriginal women courtesy of the Toronto Star

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • NewsVine
  • Current
  • email
  • Print

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. Sexist men assume that female engineers are feminists. « Restructure! on 08 Dec 2009 at 5:57 pm

    [...] times more likely to die of violence than women of any other race in Canada. Jessica Yee remembers violence against women who are much less likely to be remembered. * It is also interesting to note that a female engineer and survivor of the massacre had yelled, [...]

  2. Does Feminist = Pro Sex Work ? « .Elise.Anne. on 18 Dec 2009 at 2:43 pm

    [...] Jessica Yee says, cross-posted at Racialicious, Women forget that while we show up to vigils and talk up a nice speech about some “poor [...]

  3. Does Feminism = Pro Sex Worker? « .Elise.Anne. on 18 Dec 2009 at 5:45 pm

    [...] Jessica Yee says, cross-posted at Racialicious, Women forget that while we show up to vigils and talk up a nice speech about some “poor [...]

Comments

  1. Super Amanda wrote:

    Great post, thanks. I think too many in the straight community mock same sex domestic abuse as sort of “par for the course” and that once same sex couples pair off they supposed to just “go about their business quietly.” Even in GLBT friendly San Francisco where I’m originally from, this is still an issue, especially when bdsnm is involved as some relationships can turn from exploratory to exploitative.

    Regarding the memorial, it may not be popular but I’m a big believer in merging events and anniversaries with an up to date corresponding causes and people.
    I remember when a 20 year singer/rapper spook alongside Dr. Charles H. Wright at a Paul Robeson event. The performer gave an acapella rendition of the original lyrics to “Old Man River” which include the Nword. It was his way , he explained later, of saying that some struggles are just nearly not over. A flew sparks flew later but it was so worth it.

    I’m glad you are using the term Aboriginal woman as it goes along way in smashing the “cute little Eskimo stereotype” that most south of Seattle seem to still believe in. Violence towards aboriginal women in Canada and Alaska is definitely one of the most closeted, swept up subjects in women’s rights issues today. All my best to you.

  2. jvansteppes wrote:

    Sigh, thank you; after reading all the CBC articles I’m relieved to see this.
    Clearly the women killed at the Ecole Polytechnique deserve a memorial but I think its pretty wrongheaded to use this anniversary to mark a day for action regarding violence against women. It was an extreme, uncommon incident, and in focusing on it we totally distract from Canada’s 500+ missing Aboriginal women, sex workers murdered in every major city, rape culture and so on.

  3. Biancamv wrote:

    This is a great post that I think reminds us of the things we must think about and work on ALL the time in the feminist movement. Thank you for being so thoughtful.

  4. Amina wrote:

    I’m really glad you mention woman on woman violence. No one ever seems to be able to mention it, and most people don’t know what to think or how to address that issue.

    Thank You.

  5. ashlynn wrote:

    @jvansteppes,

    Do you really think the memorial distracts from that? If anything, hundreds of missing Aboriginal women constitutes some form of violence against women, and having a day of not only memorial, but action, would shine a light on that. Granted, the massacre itself is uncommon, but when you think about it, the sheer numbers of women who are exploited, murdered, tortured, abused and assaulted on a daily basis certainly constitutes a massacre, if not a kind of genocide, in itself.

    Jessica,
    Thank you for bringing up LGBT violence. At least in my opinion, the perception of many outside the community is that 1) same sex couples are so happy go lucky/bra burning femme butches out to destroy men that they are never inclined to hurt or abuse one another, and 2) gay couples already have so much twisted sex and live such twisted lives that smacking each other around is pretty much foreplay. But the fact of the matter is, many same sex-relationships tend to be so volatile (for a host of reasons, some shared with hetero couples and some not) that abuse happens very often. And the perceived sexual openness from within and outside of the LGBT community leaves many men and women susceptible to sexual abuse. Though I already had some understanding of this, it wasn’t until a close friend of mine confided in me that she was lured to another friend’s house and assaulted by her and someone else, that I realized how very real sexual and physical violence exists in the LGBT community, yet many women tend to focus on male-perpetrated abuse and misogyny- with reason, of course, but still….

  6. jvansteppes wrote:

    ashlynn: I’m sorry if I’ve offended you or come off too harshly. I guess I say that the memorial detracts from other violence because the response I hear most commonly (check out the cbc webcomments for this) is “yeah, that massacre was bad, but we don’t need a day against violence against women because its not like these kind of shootings still happen all the time.”
    That shooting was a very public catastrophe, and while lots of violence against women occurs in public (though not as publicized) it’s my opinion that equating the memorial to the issue at large fails to cover the violence that occurs in private, in the home etc. I have to admit though that my opinion as of late has largely been informed by the ways conservatives/men in denial dismiss the need to confront violence against women.