What President Obama Means to this Muslim Mama
by guest contributor Shawna, originally published at Islam On My Side
A Letter to My Sons on the Eve of a Nation’s Great Change
November 5, 2008
My Dear Sons,
If I can indicate to you the significance of Barack Obama’s election as President of the United States of America in even the smallest way, I will have succeeded with this letter. You’ve seen that I’ve spent much of this day in silence and tears. Most likely you won’t remember, but if you do, forgive my silence. I don’t know what to say. There is a great wheel of thought turning in my head. The ideas fly past before I can grasp them, to take a moment and investigate what it is I’m feeling; to grapple with the full import of what has happened in our great country. As for the tears, they are tears of joy. Never stem tears of happiness. They are like the rain that replenishes the earth.
I admit that with the curious circumstances surrounding President George W. Bush’s election into office in 2000, I lost faith in the effectiveness of U.S. democracy. In 2004, there was a repeat of 2000’s debacle, and with W’s claims of “political capital” at his fingertips, it seemed to me that our democracy may have crumbled. Hope was a match in my fingertips, it’s flame whipped out by a quick wind. But today, my beautiful and wonderful boys, my faith in our country has been restored. I once again believe that my voice, a voice that generations before me fought to assign a value to, has not only been heard and valued, it has become tenable twice over. My voice is not only that of a woman, it is that of a woman of color.
I’m certain you will grow up with the knowledge of your own ethnic roots if in no other capacity than in relation to your faith. What speaks to my heart today is that you may not struggle to find your own place in society the way I did for much of my life. The adversity I (and the rest of your extended family) faced during my years in Oklahoma,Texas and Arkansas may be something forever foreign to you. In those pre-9/11 days, there was certainly undisguised hatred for us as Muslims, but the main disgust we encountered was race-based. Years of hatred culminated, for us, in repudiation based on the darker tones of our skin in a White, Presbyterian-dominated area. Last night, around 11PM, it became clear to me that there is a chance you may grow up without facing, witnessing or being pressured to take part in this type of adversity. While this hope is certainly incredible in its scope, and perhaps unfounded, there are reasons that my heart is opened to your freedom from racial stigma.
Certainly, Obama’s election would not have happened at this time in America’s life if not for the many incredible failures of George W. Bush as America’s 43rd president. Had Bush not abused his position of power by pursuing war on unfounded reasons and overspending the “political capital” he claimed to have earned, America could not have reached a point of such openness to and even desire for change. I am greatly aware of Obama’s weaknesses as a candidate for this office. The polarity of the campaign period shed light on the many failings of each candidate searching for nomination, but I believe Obama was the best of the lot we were granted despite his lack of experience in governance, and it is my hope that he will be a capable leader–one who continues on in the traditions of his campaign; to stay focused on the issues and to work for an America truly united by refusing to engage the propaganda and slander of naysayers and ne’er-do-wells.
You were both born into a time of misunderstanding with regards to Islam. After my move to Indiana from Arkansas, I saw the race-driven hatred fall away to be replaced with a subversive reinforcement of anti-Islam sentiment. In high school, I did not yet know myself as a Muslim. That identity had always been secondary. I’m sure the discrimination I faced based on my skin color aided me in defining myself as “Other” when it came to race. With our move from Arkansas to Indiana, I saw that fade away. Instead of being characterized as Arab and Muslim by default, I was characterized as Muslim and Arab by default. Looking back, I can say the consequences of this inversion was an increased interest in faith. With your father by my side, I clung to my new Muslim identity to find that it came with its own challenges.
Yes, there was harassment, but I was not generally subjected to it. I had female friends whose faith was visible due to the cloth on their heads. They were treated with derision. “Is there a bomb in your backpack?” was a question one of my friends regularly faced as she tried to pass through a particular hallway on her way to class. A group of boys, three or four of them, would yank her bag, tug her scarf, stand in her way or simply stare her down. It hurt her, but she kept walking. For many of us at that time, there was no recourse for the overt and sometimes physical aggression we experienced in places that should have been safe. This was pre-9/11.
I will say one thing for the horrid events of September 11, 2001. Had they not happened, we as Americans would not have had the chance to plumb the depths of the hatred for and fear of the “other” that we hide within. Before 9/11, harassment was tolerated, allowed to happen with merely the shake of a head or a click of the tongue. “What a shame,” we subjects of discrimination were told. “Some people just don’t understand.” We were then laden with the responsibility to understand for them, to forgive them for their ignorance. We were expected not to educate.
9/11 ended the “do nothing” period for Muslims in America and around the world. Suddenly, we were targets due to the crimes of those who perpetuated terror in the name of our faith. Our majority was forced to stand up and shout until we were blue in the face that we do not tolerate, accept or condone this type of violence. That we, the Muslim masses, believe in democracy, in the freedom of religion the Constitution promises.
We could no longer sit idly by. Our friends and family were being whisked away to detention centers, fathers and mothers and sisters and brothers detained, tortured, murdered in response to the acts of unilateral thinkers whose views we did not share. We had to speak up, to claim in voices rough with tears that we are people too. Like those minorities before us, we will not be denied our civil rights in a country we love because of its promised equality. Perhaps the writers of the Constitution were not so forward thinking when they promised freedom of religion–perhaps it only applied to those who worship in churches–but we would not let our mosques be riddled with bullets or burned to the ground.
My precious boys, neither of you is old enough to understand why the tears keep falling from my eyes yet I cannot stop smiling. My silent treatment of you will likely be forgiven by its omission from your memories. I am writing this because I want you to understand the incredible blessings of the world you have been born into. There is adversity at every corner, but with adversity comes hope. Barack Obama’s election proves this. He is a man of color elected as president in a country built from the blood of minorities. He is not a Muslim. He did not make a strong standing for Muslims in his campaign, but unlike his contemporaries, he has not incited hatred against us, derided us for our beliefs or used our differences of faith as cause to exclude us from our rightful category of American.
Here is what Obama’s election means to me: Yes, you will still grow up in a minority. You, like all humans, will face challenges day by day. But you are starting your lives in a world much different than that one I grew up in–in a world that has wildly changed. It may be that you will have more doors open to you based on your diversity. You are starting your lives in an America embracing a new reflection in the world’s mirror. I hope you help to keep that reflection crisp and clean. I hope your journey toward self-identification is filled with opportunity. You are the newest generation of American Muslims. Today I am able to believe that perhaps once another half a century has passed, you will be leaders for this great country. Perhaps, now that we are moving past race-based limitations, faith-based limitations will also begin to fail. Perhaps, one day, you will inspire hope for those both like and unlike you, your heads held high, your voices lifted as you say it: Yes we can.
I pray that you’ll find these words some day and that they will illuminate a history that seems to you fashioned of fiction. May you grow up knowing only the equality our constitution promises and the beauty of democracy at its best. May you grow up free from the hate that has plagued this country for far too long. May you grow up free. May you grow up Muslim Americans.
All my love,
Your Mother

Carmen Van Kerckhove is co-founder and president of
Fatemeh wrote:
Great post, Shawna. Barikallah! Enshallah we’ll see this country become the same beautiful place it is in our hearts.
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 1:31 pm ¶
Joselle wrote:
“Never stem tears of happiness. They are like the rain that replenishes the earth.”
And with that, I started crying again.
Thank you for a beautiful post.
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 2:22 pm ¶
Sobia wrote:
You are much more optimistic than I am Shawna. I’m not sure if this is because I’m in Canada or what, but the amount of ACCEPTABLE Islamophobia I saw in this recent campaign absolutely and completely shocked me! I had no idea how immensely intense the hatred of ALL things Muslim was in the US. From the way the campaign was held I’m surprised there are no concentration camps in the US for Muslims.
But this is a view from an outsider. Perhaps it is not as bad inside as it seems from here. From this post it seems it may not be as bad as I have imagined it.
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 3:56 pm ¶
Nick wrote:
It’s fear.
The hatred is based on fear and ignorance.
I know because I once hated due to fear and ignorance.
Even though I’m an atheist, god bless you.
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 5:23 pm ¶
Shawna wrote:
Thank you Fatemeh, Joselle and Nick.
Sobia–I can’t believe how much was accepted either. But I also am fairly certain that if Obama had stepped up and said what Colin Powell did (bless his heart), he wouldn’t have been able to win this election. There are too many Americans still too uncertain about Muslims in the US or Muslims in general.
As Nick said, the hatred is based on fear and ignorance, and that was what the Republican party worked so hard to tap into. I don’t think 21 months is enough time to fully address this fear, but I have high hopes that Obama will begin to do so now that he is in office. I’m sad to have said the above, but I do remain optimistic. God willing I’m not overly so.
Maybe it took a war of religions to get past a war of race? I hope not. I’m just happy we’ve reached a point where we aren’t judged on skin. Since skin’s on the outside, clothes must be next, right?
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 6:54 pm ¶
Sobia wrote:
@Shawna:
“But I also am fairly certain that if Obama had stepped up and said what Colin Powell did (bless his heart), he wouldn’t have been able to win this election. There are too many Americans still too uncertain about Muslims in the US or Muslims in general.”
I agree and I think that’s what makes me so sad about the situation. I too believe that if he had come to our defense he would not have been elected regardless of what Bush did or didn’t do. More years of screwed up Republican policies would have been more acceptable than someone who would defend Muslims. It seems to me that those votes that made the difference would have gone to McCain – the one who hates Muslims.
I also know that if Obama had been a Muslim there would have been no way in hell he would have been elected. He wouldn’t have even made it half as far. Makes me so sad
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 7:59 pm ¶
Jill wrote:
That was a beautiful letter Shawna, thank you for sharing it
I am so happy Obama won, I have great hope that he will use his now-secure position to promote true equality and a n acceptance of how precious and valuable diversity really is.
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 9:19 pm ¶
Gwendolyn H. Barry wrote:
magnificent! intelligently filled with open heart. this is a woman of awesome power, love.
Posted 06 Nov 2008 at 11:26 pm ¶
Kat wrote:
For strategic reasons, maybe Obama and his campaign had to be silent (what a horrible commentary that is on our country), but he could have made up for it and pointedly mentioned Muslims along with the other groups in his acceptance speech, given all the vitriol and hate spewed against him, Muslims and Arabs and his silence or defensiveness during the campaign, and he didn’t. I was very disappointed in an otherwise joyous night. I wish I could be as optimistic as you, Shawna, but I think I have been around too long to be optimistic about any substantive change in our policies or our attitudes towards Muslims and Arabs .
Posted 09 Nov 2008 at 4:26 pm ¶
Emily wrote:
A wonderfully accurate and inspiring letter. Obama’s victory is one of hope and optimism for much needed change and acceptance in the US
Posted 10 Nov 2008 at 3:15 am ¶
Sobia wrote:
@Kat:
“but he could have made up for it and pointedly mentioned Muslims along with the other groups in his acceptance speech”
You noticed it too eh? I was wishing he had too and although I thoroughly enjoyed his speech I couldn’t help but think he left Muslims and/or Arabs out on purpose. Maybe it’s still not safe to say the ‘M’ word yet. Or the ‘A’ word.
And I just heard something about how he voted to renew the Patriotic Act, one of the most Islamophobic legislations ever.
But you know, despite all this I can’t help but feel that somewhere deep down inside he does really like us. But he can’t show it. And that’s the only reason I don’t get discouraged by him.
Posted 10 Nov 2008 at 9:10 pm ¶
Shawna wrote:
@ Kat and Sobia–
I actually was holding my breath hoping we’d get a shout-out. I’m watching with concern, and I don’t have any illusion that we’re post-racist now in this country, but I do think we’re showing great progress. I mean, even if it’s only 52% of the country pro-change, that’s still an incredible amount more than we would have found, say, three years ago.
I am very wary of what Obama’s choices will be, but he comes from such a multi-ethnic background that I am rooted in optimism on what his global and internal policies might be. I believe he can’t just rescind everything Bush has done in his first year. I think he has to be cautious, keep that other half of the US citizenry with him until he has their trust, then make the changes that will restore rights to American minorities.
But I know I don’t want to be that person saying, “He’ll get there. He’ll get there,” and waiting for a day that just never comes. So mostly I’m excited about what this means for what Americans want and are ready for–not so much for who is in the White House. What say you?
Posted 12 Nov 2008 at 4:09 pm ¶