Why We Want Our Kids Back Too

by Guest Contributor Black Canseco

I grew up in the inner cities of Chicago—places where buses hate to stop, and cabs hate to come. My parents worked hard. Most of our neighbors worked hard. Some people tried. Some people just gave up. Others gave up while they tried and vice versa.

When there was violence, we cried and tried to stop it. When there was death we cried, wondered why and tried to deal with it. But we had to do these things alone.

There were no crush of grief counselors when our 11 year olds got shot by strays or on purpose. There were no pundits filling column space and air time when our girls got raped or became pregnant too soon. And when our children came up missing… when our children came up missing…

When our children came up missing there was silence. Silence and indifference. There still is.

I saw enough missing and dead black kids coming up that it taught me something about black folks, or at least the way black folks are perceived:

Black children are disposable expectations.

Black girls are expected to become mothers too soon. Black kids are expected to be dead too soon. Black boys are expected to become criminals. Black students are expected to dropout of school. Black youth are expected to grow into the lesser-thans that we fear and secretly prefer they become.

When people have those sorts of expectations of you, an attitude of disposability follows. It has to.

When my neighbor’s kid Brandon got hit by an unforeseen and still unidentified car she didn’t talk to anyone for 6 months. Not a word for anyone. One day she came over to mom’s house and said, “I’m still a mother, I’m just the mother of a dead child now.”

I’ve lost track of the number of black girls and boys under 21 that got abducted, vanished, or killed. I’ve lost track of the number of mothers, husbands, and children that have screamed for help from police and media and other communities only to be ignored. Outside of our blocks and neighborhoods no one cares.

Simultaneously, I’ve lost track of the white kids and white women from seemingly 8-80 that receive local, regional, national and even international attention when they are missing, molested, harmed or who aren’t allowed fulfill their “expectations.”

Everything from runaway brides to vacationing coeds to murdered military moms to snatched up toddlers and housewives. Be they rich, poor, rural, suburban or city, missing white women and white teens are valued. They are cherished. When violence befalls them it is “news”. It is a surprise that it happened to them—where they live. Theirs are the tragedies that must be covered. They are the victimized who must be championed. Their families are the ones deserving of justice and closure. Their families cannot be left to cope alone. They are the lost that must be found.


Nancy Grace doesn’t have an aneurysm on camera when LaToya goes missing. Dan Abrams doesn’t get outraged when Marcus or Jamar vanishes. Katie Couric and Barabara Walters don’t break down in tears when kids from South Central are murdered. Bill O’Reilly and Keith Olbermann don’t interrupt your program when Jaunita is found chopped up into pieces. Magazines and newspapers aren’t tracking those cases. They’re just not news enough or “human interest” enough for all of that.

Ironically, according to the FBI, the National Center of Missing and Exploited Children and other orgs, most of missing children (those under 18) in America are neither white nor female. In fact 33% of all missing children under 18 are African American girls; overall, it’s believed that Black, Hispanic and Asian Americans account for over 40% of all missing children under 18. As for missing adults (those over 18), the National Center of Missing Adults, FBI, and other orgs have report similar findings.

Lastly, the Amber Alert, which was originally designed for missing children under the age of 18, yet has no set national criteria for use (guidelines vary by state) has been under attack from critics claiming it’s used mostly for white female adults, many of whom haven’t been abducted but have “runaway” or have voluntarily left their environments.

These kinds of hypocrisies and disparities drove me to look for ways to help. That’s how I discovered great child advocacy sites like Missing Minorities, What About Our Daughters? and Black And Missing. Since I used to write ads for a living, I figured I could do something they could use—and the We Want Our Kids Back, Too campaign was born.

We Want Our Kids Back, Too is a viral web campaign that combines picks of missing and endangered children of color (Black, Hispanic, Asian, mixed race/multicultural, etc.) with commentary challenging all to consider disparities in coverage, outrage and concern. Each ad highlights a different child/teen and reminds us that they are just as human just as “all-american” as Jesse Davis, Natalee Holloway, Elizabeth Smart and all the rest who receive so much focus. The ads also encourage us all to do better about giving all children a fighting chance for safe recovery regardless of ethnicity and background.

Please visit www.photobucket.com/ourmissingkids where you’ll find all sorts of fresh ads to grab and spread around and re-post. You can also find them at www.hustleknockin.com.

Note: Posters are being updated and added frequently, as there is no shortage of missing kids of color and no shortage of parents, relatives and friends who want their safe recovery. So check back often and take the posters and spread them around as you see fit.

Edited:

Black Canseco mentions in the comments:

If you reach out to sites like these:

http://www.WhatAboutOurDaughters.com
blackandmissing.blogspot.com/
missingminorities.blogspot.com/

you’ll find more children of all backgrounds that are missing. the sheer numbers are staggering; and again, the lack of coverage seem to reflect a bigger problem.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • NewsVine
  • Current
  • email
  • Print

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. We Want Our Kids Back, Too « don’t do that on 15 Aug 2008 at 9:29 am

    [...] Racialicious: There were no crush of grief counselors when our 11 year olds got shot by strays or on purpose. [...]

  2. “We want our kids back too” « The Bead Shop on 18 Aug 2008 at 4:29 am

    [...] Posted in media, theory by Zenobia on August 18th, 2008 I’d urge you to go and read this beautifully-written and important post by Black Canseco at Racialicious, on all the missing black, hispanic and asian kids who don’t [...]

  3. CRANKY « Fugitivus on 10 Sep 2008 at 12:01 pm

    [...] Non-White kids get kidnapped, too [...]

  4. muslim children gassed in ohio - but where’s the outrage? at Racialicious - the intersection of race and pop culture on 01 Oct 2008 at 6:00 am

    [...] Why We Want Our Kids Back Too From Racialicious: There were no crush of grief counselors when our 11 year olds got shot by strays or on purpose. There were no pundits filling column space and air time when our girls got raped or became pregnant too soon. And when our children came up missing… when our children came up missing…I saw enough missing and dead black kids coming up that it taught me something about black folks, or at least the way black folks are perceived: [...]

  5. Hell No! Muslim Children Gassed in Dayton « The Cruel Secretary on 26 Aug 2009 at 3:02 pm

    [...] Why We Want Our Kids Back TooFrom Racialicious There were no crush of grief counselors when our 11 year olds got shot by strays or on purpose. There were no pundits filling column space and air time when our girls got raped or became pregnant too soon. And when our children came up missing… when our children came up missing…I saw enough missing and dead black kids coming up that it taught me something about black folks, or at least the way black folks are perceived: Black children are disposable expectations. [...]

Comments

  1. Brian wrote:

    Beautifully written, Canseco. Thank you for this. I’ll spread it as best I can.

  2. Niki wrote:

    You have managed to both touch my heart and rage against a society that consistently devalues non-white lives. While I feel for parents of any color that suffer through the horror of a missing or abducted child, I am always curious to see the attention and support (or lack thereof) that families of color receive.

  3. emfole wrote:

    im confused- why are these photos put through a photoshop filter? it would be hard to recognize a person from these photos…why are there no height/color etc. stats to better spot the missing kids? are these children who are missing now?

  4. Cynthia wrote:

    Does it also depend on where you live and the parents’ background(s)?

    The Cecilia Zhang case was top of the news over here in 2003, overshadowing the municipal elections. The case was even covered by America’s Most Wanted.

    More info from the Globe and Mail (from 2006)

  5. Latoya Peterson wrote:

    Emfole –

    Black Conseco’s campaign is to raise awareness about the issue, in tandem with what the other sites are doing to actually help find these children.

    You can visit all the sites that are hyperlinked in the main section for more information about all the missing children.

    You can also go to the full photobucket site, where BC has created a lot of different posters, pictures, site buttons, and messages to help pass things along.

  6. Ali wrote:

    Canseco, this is a very interesting and insightful piece. I’m happy to see folks like you who are motivated to the point of action when they see a wrong that they can help to make right. The line from your piece that will stay with me the longest is:

    “When people have those sorts of expectations of you, an attitude of disposability [sic] follows. It has to.”

    I see this attitude, this culture of complacency, very prevalently where I live and I’m curious as to what you think are effective tools to combat it. I understand why it happens but internalizing this type of messaging is extremely dangerous. If the population at large doesn’t care about you, and you lose faith in yourself, what do you have left?

    The woman who waited 6 months to tell anyone about the murder of her own child reminds me of the Ramona Moore murder. A neighbor’s son was actually led (by “friends”) to the basement where she was being held and tortured and didn’t tell a soul for several days. I can’t imagine the horror of being a child, growing up in these communities and not being able to turn to adults for guidance and leadership.

  7. Karen Franklin, Ph.D wrote:

    Canseco -

    Wonderful essay. There’s a whole ‘nother world out there that the mainstream media ignores. Thanks to you for trying to break the silence.

    - Karen Franklin, Ph.D.
    Forensic Psychologist
    http://forensicpsychologist.blogspot.com/

  8. anonymous wrote:

    Disposability was not misspelled.

  9. DiosaNegra1967 wrote:

    Thank you, Canseco……

  10. RJG wrote:

    I think it’s a total shame that there’s only a photobucket account (and a typepad blog) for this campaign. Is there any kind of official website for this in the works?

  11. RJG wrote:

    edit: didn’t read the fine print under the posters themselves. Could those sites be added to the original post at the end or something with the two already mentioned?

  12. Eric Daniels wrote:

    This is what saddens me the most in modern Black Life in the inner cities when we have used to have a community now it’s a neighborhood of strangers and it makes it so easy for our kids and missing women and men to be dismissed unlike the baby who is being promoted on Nancy Grace like there is no tommorrow. We need to create more stable communities in the post -black flight era.

  13. Ali wrote:

    Thanks anonymous #8. My spell-check lied to me.

  14. Kris wrote:

    I generally ignore those alerts about missing people anyways, which puts me at a whole different level of social irresponsibility. I had never even noticed or thought about the reports being only about white kids, but I’m not surprised.

    I really appreciate that the program exists, and that you shared it with us. To me, this is exactly where racial injustice needs to be fought: in the areas where there are obvious problems that can be attacked with objective solutions.

    There is simply no reason why one missing person should be sought after while another one is not. I shuddered reading this entry; I simply cannot fathom what it must be like living in that environment. I will do my best to help spread the word! Thanks!

  15. Monie wrote:

    I think the problem regarding the MSM not covering missing people of color is more myopia than racism.

    I think most people are most interested in the plight/ wellbeing of people that look like them or the people that live in close proximity.

    If you have ever had the (dis)pleasure of witnessing a producers meeting at a MSM network outlet you would see that pretty much everyone in the room is White and mostly male. I think White producers are simply more interested in people that look like them than people that don’t.

    I know that we expect the media to be unbiased and professional but the truth is they are just fallible people like the rest of us.

    Will this change over time? Only as the demographics of this country change will this change. When White people are no longer the majority, which is quickly coming, will this change.

    In the mean time I’m happy to see that people of color are being proactive and creating their (our) own media to deal with the issue.

  16. Brian wrote:

    I’ve got a question that just popped into my head. I don’t know the answer, but here is another possible horrible consequence of the way the media reports this: black kids aren’t WORTH kidnapping.

    Maybe it’s completely ridiculous, but is it also possible that, as a result of all that BC writes, people who rely on the MSM for their information re: kidnappings just assume no one wants to steal a little black kid? Lordy…

  17. Black Canseco wrote:

    Thx for all the comments. I was really inspired by the other sites and groups pushing this issue and i just wanted to throw my two cents in to help.

    If you reach out to sites like these:

    http://www.WhatAboutOurDaughters.com
    blackandmissing.blogspot.com/
    missingminorities.blogspot.com/

    you’ll find more children of all backgrounds that are missing. the sheer numbers are staggering; and again, the lack of coverage seem to reflect a bigger problem.

  18. Black Canseco wrote:

    Brian,

    the idea of who’s worth kidnapping would be valid were it not for the numbers of the children of color being kidnapped. You’re talking about a near 40% snatch rate here. Clearly somebody thinks enough of black, hispanic and asian american kids to kidna/do harm to them.

    Tho there was a recent case of a serial killer called the Green River Killer who intentionally chose what he called “undesirable victims”—prostitutes, women of color, poor white women, because he believe nobody would miss them. in around ‘03 Gary Rdgway confessed to killing 48 women.

    Along the US/Mexico border, an estimated 300 primarily Mexican/Mexican American women have been murdered. Little coverage beyond the “immigrant/illegals” angle has been given to this story.

    it’s sad all the way around.

  19. Sulyp wrote:

    @ Brian, you’ve hit something spot on.

    I think it is the “inherent” worthiness of the individual that garners various levels of outreach and sympathetic outpouring. In this society, it often means those who are white & female, petite/young/blonde are preferred.

    I remember when I was watching a “True Hollywood Story” program on “E” about the Chandra Levy case, and I discovered that there were two other women that disappeared in the same local area under similar circumstances in a relatively short period of time. One of them was a white woman, who received almost as much attention in her local news as Levy, the other one was an Asian woman who received almost no attention at all. Even on the “THS” program, the Asian family received scant mentions. It may be that they may have wanted their privacy, but the glaring lack of attention to her was alarming to me.

    This made me examine my own assumptions about Asian women being kidnapped… I hadn’t thought it was a problem in the US, but apparently it does happen.

  20. Free wrote:

    Props to Black Canseco.

    I’m thinking about the Plight of Mixed-Race Kids study at Freakanomics in which violent behavior is ascribed to black kids (and by extension I bet in many minds, Latinos, poor Asian, and poor white kids). It’s like you said Black Canseco, disposable. For mixed-race kids the so-called advantage of being “more attractive” doesn’t help even though we live in a culture that regards attractive people as more socially acceptable and therefore entitled to certain advantages.

    Nancy Grace should be ashamed. :(

  21. Black Canseco wrote:

    Monie,

    I think there’s something to the “not like us/out of mind” theory that many newsrooms have. I’ve seen it in the ad world, where we throw around demos such as “18-34 year old” but aren’t thinking about ethnic 18-34 year olds of color because the marketers themselves are white and those folks are not like them.

    The only problem with this is like marketing, news isn’t supposed to be about what’s/who’s “top of mind” or who’s most relatable. News is supposed to diverse and inclusive, by definition as “news” happens to everyone.

    Missing children, violence, drug abuse, war, etc. are going on in all communities. To simply focus/highlight these issues when it impacts the same people as if those people are the only ones that matter is just bad reporting.

    So why does it go on when folks clearly know better?

  22. Alexandra wrote:

    Thank you so much for this wonderful post about these horrible disparities.

  23. Arturo wrote:

    So, I posted this topic on another, ’social networking’ board I frequent. The first two responses were callbacks to Soul Asylum’s “Runaway Train” song. After I asked the guy who posted the Weird al parody of the song, I was told that the dude was trying to “put a smile” on the thread. A few posts later I got this post:

    “You know why there are so many missing black or hispanic kids? because they are throw-away kids. They are bastards born to parents who are too young to care, to poor to take care of them, or too high or drunk.
    I’m not saying that it’s not a problem but how do kids go missing??? Because someone isn’t WATCHING out for them.”

  24. C-Marsh wrote:

    Great essay! Sad subject matter..

    I always noticed the media frenzy when white children went missing and never saw the same reciprocated for PoCs, but I never knew the numbers of missing/abducted PoC children was soooo large. Thanks for opening my eyes!!

    In reference to serial killers, Dahmer was also one who was able to kill for so long without getting caught because of the race of his victims. He lived in a predominately black neighborhood and the majority of his victims were black. The disappearances were usually discounted by the police. I doubt the same would have happened had this happened in a white neighborhood.

  25. Renee wrote:

    The disparity between how missing children are treated really hit home again with the recent coverage of Caylee Anthony. In the same period three children of color went missing and there was barely a mention of it in the mainstream media. I found myself asking where is our front page news story and our amber alert? This is about who we choose to value in this society and it is based in race and class.

  26. Arturo wrote:

    Hm. Question: I’m looking up the NCMEC stats on abductees and runaways, but the stats they cite don’t have any listings for Asians. Am I just looking in the wrong spot?

  27. J wrote:

    thanks black canseco for writing this. i was thinking the same thing yesterday evening. they seem to be doing 24 hour coverage on that little girl that’s missing. a few weeks ago in chicago they had a 10 year anniversary of ryan harris’ murder. she was black, and she was 10. i remember it getting coverage here, but i don’t even know if anyone outside the chicagoland area heard about the case. and she wasn’t missing. she was murdered! why does it take murdering kids of color before they’re worthy of press – and sometimes not even then? obviously, on some level, it’s understood that we don’t matter. we are objects. we can be kidnapped and tortured and killed, and no one outside our communities will know, or care even.

  28. Kendra wrote:

    Thanks so much for this article and the links. Would it be possible to get an embeddable slideshow of the photos and posters on the photobucket account? I’d love to put more than one image on my website.

  29. emfole wrote:

    Why why are these photos pixilated??

  30. Black Canseco wrote:

    Kendra, Black And Missing has slide shows. I’ll see if i can get a link for you.

    to Arturo,

    All i can say about that poster and those who think that way is 2 things: (1) so what about the missing white kids? are their parents juvenile delinquent potheads or are kidnappers simply knocking them upside the head and snatching their precious cargo as they live and breathe? (2) it’s thinking like this that empowers child abuse. “Yeah, they had it coming….”

    way to go, sparky.

  31. curlyscales wrote:

    Question – do people really care more or is this “concern” more about the selling of sex? I just don’t see any real concern for the plight of abused and missing children. What I see are ratings that seem to be exaggerated around young, white females.

  32. Monie wrote:

    “So why does it go on when folks clearly know better?” – Black Canseco

    Because it’s the status quo; everyone does it so there is really no incentive to change.

    If there was a network that began to focus on the story rather than the ethnicity of the person/ people at the center of the story, it would force others to do the same.

    Also because the majority of producers are White there is usually no one in the room to speak up/ advocate for stories that involve people of color.

    There is a ton of money to be made by focusing news on people of color (and not the traditional problematic story) if a media outlet would just do it. There is a huge pent-up desire for more diverse news coverage. I’m amazed that the money hungry parent companies of the news outlets haven’t realized that and tried to cash-in. Now that to me is something to be explored, their rational for ignoring the financial gain aspect of diversity.

  33. Shauna wrote:

    That intro was so gripping.

    But I agree with other comments that the ads would be more aesthetically pleasing (and thus would raise more awareness) with better quality or differently edited photos. The words at the top are really effective but those at the bottom are very hard to read, at least at this size.

    There should be an email/call campaign to get Nancy Grace to stop giving non-stop coverage to missing white girls, and start using some of that time for non-white missing girls and boys.

  34. Erin wrote:

    @Monie:
    “I think White producers are simply more interested in people that look like them than people that don’t.”

    and that’s not racism? if you don’t think that’s racism, then we are clearly operating with different definitions of the term.

  35. Jaye wrote:

    This post is too sad. It is crazy reading something like this. I can’t believe the majority of the audience for CNN or Nancy Grace would be less likely to call in with tips about a missing black or asian child than a white child. Unfortunately, you can’t call in if you don’t even know the child is missing.

    I agree with Shauna, there should be some kind of campaign to change this. I think some of the broadcasters do the story of the missing white people because that has been the status-quo. I would like to think that broadcasters like Abrams and Olbermann put the story on because it’s already the story, (hopefully) not because they deliberately chose to focus on a white child over a black child. It’s unfair but true, if you want this to change, it needs to be organized from the ground up.

  36. Renee wrote:

    @Shauna
    There should be an email/call campaign to get Nancy Grace to stop giving non-stop coverage to missing white girls, and start using some of that time for non-white missing girls and boys.
    People of color have been talking about the lack of coverage of crimes committed against us for decades. The media is no oblivious to what they are doing. They completely realize that they are sending out value coded messages by showing only white female bodies. It tells White women be good and we will look for you if the dark hordes ravage you and it tells POC what we already know- we don’t count in this society.

  37. jed wrote:

    I do not follow the missing-du-jour stories because newsrooms treat them as filler and eye-candy to draw eyeballs to screens.

    As for Nancy Grace, she is not a journalist and her show is not news.

  38. Michelle wrote:

    Thank you Erin.

    Monie, the theory of “being more comfortable with people who look like you” is very close to the theory that human beings for centuries use many different types of reasons to devalue other humans. Many scholars feel that it was one of the main reasons for slavery and genocide throughout the world.

    If you can’t see the inherent value of a young Black girl, who is taken from her home and being tortured somewhere, if you need some Black person to say “Hey, she deserves to be found and rescued as well”, then perhaps you have gone beyond racism and you simply don’t see Blacks as human or worthwhile.

  39. Rchoudh wrote:

    This is just so sad and scary. Does this apathy towards finding missing POC children also extend to the police? In other words do the police not show as much interest and zeal towards finding POC children as they would with whites? I imagine finding that out would be difficult if not impossible.

    As for the media I remember how they once blatantly revealed their preference for covering white children stories. When the 2006 story of the young Iraqi girl’s rape-murder by US soldiers first broke it was initially overshadowed by the resurrection of the JonBenet Ramsey story. Both were not given equal coverage at the same time even though they both involved young pretty victims of rape-murder. It wasn’t until the Ramsey story died down again that the other story was finally given airtime. This just made me realize that even a decade old cold case file can once again receive media coverage if it involves a young white female.

  40. Bob Simpson wrote:

    I worked at a South Side Chicago high school for many years. I always felt like I was in a war zone: Wealthy White America against South Side Chicago.

    The school was a multi-racial working class women’s high school so everyone there was intimately affected by this nation’s dangerous intersection of race, class and gender. Affected in different ways obviously, but you could hardly ignore it.

    Young people from that part of the world could simply disappear as Black Canseco described or wind up dead.The corporate owned news media rarely noticed and with honorable exceptions noted, obviously didn’t care.

    I only hope that the efforts described by Black Canseco get the funding and attention they deserve.

    All young people deserve a chance to make their contribution to society no matter where they live, who their parents are and what color they happen to be.

  41. Shauna wrote:

    @Renee

    In my opinion modern racism is predominantly subconscious. Therefore the reporters look for what’s newsworthy, and happen to subconsciously find missing white girls more “newsworthy” than others that are missing. Then others report the same thing that other reporters have previously started. It ends up with abysmal coverage of non-white missing people. That’s just my opinion though, call into Nancy Grace and ask her that. See what she says.

  42. Fatemeh wrote:

    I can’t add anything but my gratitude. Great post; it needs to written and written and written until the media gets it.

  43. Jeane Goforth wrote:

    Thank you. This has been irritating me and you’ve given me something to do about it.

  44. Shanae wrote:

    Thank you so very much for posting this commentary. I get so discouraged with the news media after reading things like this. I’ve read your article, I’ve visited the sites you listed, I’ve looked at each photo carefully and I still feel helpless. The reality that there is a group of individuals, some paid and some unpaid, who collectively made the decision that certain people and their stories are not interesting enough or simply do not matter enough breaks my heart.

  45. Pheagan wrote:

    This is amazing. It reminds me, also, of the fact that while we cry about the PTSD and plight of American soldiers in Iraq, we don’t seem to give a fuck not only that they are often killing Iraqi women and children, but also that the depleted uranium used in this and the past Gulf war has caused a huge trend of horrific birth defects in the countries effected. It’s not just that they’re our ënemy”; their color feeds into our utter lack of empathy while we “support our troops”. Bravo.

  46. Torontonian wrote:

    I don’t like how the pictures are pixelized *and* deformed along the vertical axis.

    The first missing child, Daja Hunter, looks like she’s 16 because of the stretching, while the in the original photo, she looks like 11 or something. The third child, Veronica Ruiz, is stretched out horribly and lightened and looks East Asian, while in the original photo, her skin tone is darker, she doesn’t look East Asian, and she just looks like a different person.

    The stretching and pixelization makes these kids unrecognizable. It makes them look uglier, especially those black dots around the black kids’ faces that look like pimples, while the original photos have clear skin.

    I appreciate what you’re doing, but the photoshopping is unnecessary.

  47. Latoya Peterson wrote:

    @All -

    I am not approving any more comments that critique the photoshopping of the campaign.

    If you don’t like it, here’s a thought – VOLUNTEER. That way, you have some input into the final product.

    And thank Black Conseco for the work he has done on this up to this point. It is very easy to launch a bunch of criticisms, much harder to actually participate.

  48. Monie wrote:

    Michelle & Erin,

    I think that when we have a problem like this it is important to identify the thought process and mechanisms that allow the problem to fester.

    It’s easy to say racism is the problem but that does not move the conversation forward. The conversation moves (toward a solution) once we know why something occurs rather than just that it occurs.

    My comment(s) was an effort to show that it’s not as simple as someone making a decision to ignore POC in these situations. That it’s more of a systematic problem in which POC are excluded because there are very few POC decision makers in the media.

    The solution as I’ve alluded to is to have a more diverse population of producers at network outlets.

  49. Black Canseco wrote:

    I just want to address a couple points:

    Yes I photoshopped the pictures. I did so because in most cases the only pictures available are too small or too pixelated for reproduction to begin with. Most people don’t plan on having their child abducted and don’t keep headshots and media-quality pics of their loved ones on hand. They post the pics they have, which aren’t always of the best quality.

    Anyone with a problem with the quality of pics or the ads is free to create their own or offer photography services to families as a “just in case” measure.

    Other photos were stretched to fit the layouts i created. It was the only way to get all the copy and pics in together.

    While i work on improving my photoshop skills, my hope is that others work on spreading the word about missing kids. And if you think you can create better ads, i’ll happily send the elements to anyone who wants them so that you can put together your own to the specs you see fit.

  50. Marge Twain wrote:

    @Monie:
    “I think the problem regarding the MSM not covering missing people of color is more myopia than racism.”

    “Also because the majority of producers are White there is usually no one in the room to speak up/ advocate for stories that involve people of color.”

    “It’s easy to say racism is the problem but that does not move the conversation forward”

    What you’re describing is how racism works, not something apart from racism. It starts with the discrimination in hiring that is rampant in the media world, which one could call “the inability of white people to see people of color as qualified” and continues with racist choices on which stories to cover or, alternately, “white people merely seeing crimes against people of other races as unremarkable”

    It is certainly helpful, as you said, to dig into why people make certain choices, but we also need to recognize racism and call it out if we hope to dismantle it. Racism is almost always unintentional. Folks generally do not set out to exclude, but then their values reveal themselves through their actions, and the result, not the conscious intention is how we measure racism.

    More diversity in newsrooms would certainly be a good thing, but if all those people are merely advocating for members of their own race, then we have not overcome much.

  51. Candelaria wrote:

    So important and so true. This disparity in outrage, reportage locally and nationally has been going on for decades. It doesn’t seem to get better.
    Thanks for the post and thanks to all of the people who’ve commented.

  52. Michelle wrote:

    Marge,

    Thank you for articulating my thoughts so clearly.

    I completely agree, when newsrooms/classrooms/operating rooms are diverse just so that people can “advocate for members of their own race, then we have not overcome much”. In my imagination, the goal of anti-racists is that the inherent value of a human being is not based on skin color, sexual orientation or gender. To say that the devaluation of a human being is not conscious and there fore should not be labeled as racism, is like taking a step backward. Also, if racism is not a “why”, then what is it? Just a label that angry POC lob at “the man”? Racism is real and certainly a reason “why” things happen.

  53. Helena wrote:

    I guess at this point–no, I can’t disagree.

    I can’t disagree that the MSM coverage of missing people in general is pretty bad, especially for missing women and children of color.

    Two things, though:

    1) John Walsh and the NCMEC (the source you used) TRY to keep track of non-white victims. Maybe not all of them, but more than Fox.

    2) Nancy Grace (not a fan, but was still surprised to see it on her show) covered the kidnapping/murder of Tamika Houston,the as-yet-open case of Chanel Petro-Nixon, and Tionda/Diamond Bradley.

    If the media actually tried to cover every man, woman and child who was abducted by parents, acquaintances, boyfriends/husbands and strangers…those without criminal ties (and thus, special enemies) alone would need an entire 24 hour channel. (Fine by me!)

    The picture is bleaker than you paint it…people aren’t as informed about the plight of missing and abducted white kids either; ask the next person on the street who Elizabeth Smart is (does it matter? What’s to be learned from the case, other than to fear that a drifter you hire might come back for you or your family?) or who Jessica Lunsford is. Unless you’re a perpetrator, witness/person with a tip, a donor, or a search volunteer….how much does the size of the audience really help?

    What’s to be learned from informing oneself that most victims know their attackers? What can an outsider do if a black girl’s neighborhood is terrorized by local pimps/drug dealers or if non-white women are threatened by their own boyfriends or relatives? (Other than donating/volunteering… is that enough?)

    I’ll say this…if the audience for these horrible stories doesn’t matter…MSM pressure on police and potential tips are what’s important. (I don’t think the media can be blamed if nobody offers a lead…even Al Sharpton tried to help with the Chanel Petro-Nixon case…nobody in her neighborhood spoke up. She was found cut up in 2006).

  54. merq wrote:

    BC,

    Nothing really to add, but had to say thanks for this incredibly insightful post.

  55. Mars wrote:

    I wonder if this is yet another disparity that ties back into problems with a limited network. The stories that normally get a lot of attention are the ones when someone fairly well off disappears from a quiet area. I think its not only that no one expects them to go missing, its that when they go missing they’re the child whose parents are friends of a friend of a reporter or someone else with the ability to pub it and cares about the kid personally.

    At the same time when cops in a high crime area are investigating a missing child report its one of hundreds instead of maybe one of ten. I can’t help but think that would just lend a hopelessness o the entire thing. To cops who are always dealing with missing child reports, a missing kid whatever their color is probably just whats expected unless there’s some connected with enough power to make a big stink.

  56. Terri wrote:

    Excellent post. Reading this, I am reminded of the story of a little boy who came up missing in the last year or two, and he was found, dead, by sanitation workers several days later after a significant amount of community involvement and legwork. I couldn’t stand to watch or read news coverage because, rather than expressing compassion for this little boy and his family, the news (and the vile comments on the newspaper web site) was more focused on the undocumented status of his mother (a worker at a very large and prominent employer in the community) and the victim’s status as an “anchor baby” than the fact that this child was likely abducted and murdered. It was absolutely despicable the way that family was spoken about.

  57. Angel H. wrote:

    Black Canseco, great post!

    I’ve e-mailed this post and the links to my friends at work. Hopefully, we can get the word around.

  58. NancyP wrote:

    Could you approach someone like the ad person for public transit, and get a share of any “public service” space on trains, buses, shelters – including those that serve white commuters? In a city like Chicago, that’s a lot of exposure.

    (yes, I know that such a move would require some political maneuvers or big connections).

  59. BewareofWhiteRacists wrote:

    Anti Racist Parent bans the voice of those who find different-race adoptions to be problematic.

    http://www.transracialabductees.org/

    It’s another example of the white middle class ignoring the realities of racism. Everything is candy-coated for white audiences.

    Racism is a very REAL problem. Spain is an example. The KKK continues to exist in America. Tim Wise (anti-racist activist) discusses how whites used to have picnics during a lynching of a non-white person.

    Mod Note – I’m going to need you to calm down.

    (1) Are you aware that Anti-Racist Parent and Racialicious are under the same parent company? I highly doubt that ARP would ban the voices of those who have issues with different race adoptions, but I find it highly likely that they would ban someone who is trying to force their opinion down the throats of others. In specific reference to the transracial adoptee experience, we highlight a variety of voices coming from all different sides in that debate. Sometimes it works out well, sometimes it doesn’t work out at all, and most people fall somewhere in the middle.

    (2) And why are you bringing up transracial adoption here? There is nothing I hate more than someone going off topic. Post your tangents elsewhere.

    (3) I highly doubt anyone on Racialicious is in doubt that racism is a real problem. I am not sure if you are aware of the values and ideas being discussed on this forum, as you keep bringing up old, established fact and presenting them as new truths. I suggest you take a few days and read through our archives and highlighted posts to understand the level of conversation appropriate on this forum.

    (4) You definitely need to get familiar with our content. Tim Wise is a commenter here and a has been guest on our podcast. (And, I must say, if you needed Tim Wise to tell you the history behind “picnics,” I’m going to need you to head back into racism 101 before you post here again.)

    (5) I’ve watched your comments for a while, and they show a stunning lack of understanding of what is going on at Racialicious. So I am putting you on a commenting break. Your comments will not be approved until you (1) learn to engage with the topic at hand, (2) understand what level of discussion is appropriate for this form and (3) find something substantial to say. – LDP

  60. Black Canseco wrote:

    Helena,

    i guess you can point to 1 or 2 cases that nancy Grace mentions and say that she’s not part of the problem. You could do the same with any MSM outlet—highlight one or two examples and say “see, they’ve got black friends, too.” so to speak.

    Also, as it relates to who is doing the violence. Crime stats across the board reveal the same issue–most criminals live within 3-5 miles of their victims. So there’s a good chance that for 85% of black victims the perp is black, for 85% of white victims the perp is white, etc. The 85% number is an estimate i’ve seen on Fbi.gov (the FBI’s site.)

    But the issue isn’t who is doing the crimes–tho that’s hugely important. The key issue i’m focusing on is which victims are deemed worthy of coverage.
    If someone cries out for help and are consistently ignored then the criminals aren’t even looked for because the crimes themselves are being measured by the so-called “quality” of the victim.

    In many ways, ethnic victims are acknowledged only as “i told you so” stats for proof that ethnic communities are inherently violent, uniquely dangerous, justifiably seen as lesser-than; yet no matter how many white victims get shine and no matter how many white perpetrators are exposed, no one (at least no one in the MSM) ever says, “see, white folks is crazy/dangerous”

    these imbalance further the disenfranchisement of communities of color.

  61. Marge Twain wrote:

    @Michelle: Thanks for the compliment; I’ve long been a fan of yours from your comments. I was actually building on what you had written above, which was plenty articulate. And I absolutely agree that not being racist neccessitates valuing the life and safety of all human beings. Like you wrote, racism is a real “why” not a cop out.

    @Black Canseco: I love that you created an opportunity to put your talents for this critically important issue. Not only does it show an ugly truth about who we value, media campaigns have been extremely helpful in finding many missing victims including Elizabeth Smart.

  62. Helena wrote:

    @BlackCanseco:

    I’m saying its remarkable missing people–black, white, Hispanic, whomever–are covered at all. It usually happens once a child is thought to have been taken over state lines, or else, they’re already DEAD and the perpetrator is on the run.

    I ultimately agree that the disproportionate lack of coverage can make a statement.

    “But the issue isn’t who is doing the crimes–tho that’s hugely important. The key issue i’m focusing on is which victims are deemed worthy of coverage.”

    How often do you really see parental kidnappings covered on news? (I’ll admit, I’ve seen a few this summer–one white family, one black; the coverage was in LOCAL news for both).

    Which gets the most coverage? Stranger/stereotypical kidnappings. Should they cover a case where a local drug dealer abducts his teenage nonwhite girlfriend? YES. And they don’t. My point is I doubt they’d do it if the victim was white either, not on TV news.

    “…ethnic victims are acknowledged only as “i told you so” stats for proof that ethnic communities are inherently violent, uniquely dangerous, justifiably seen as lesser-than; yet no matter how many white victims get shine and no matter how many white perpetrators are exposed, no one (at least no one in the MSM) ever says, “see, white folks is crazy/dangerous”

    You start off the piece discussing the endless parade of local violence; here there is endless coverage of hit-and-runs (assholes hitting kids or pedestrians in SUVS, probably under the influence, and speeding away), gun fights over something mind-bogglingly stupid, kids being raped or abducted….if it’s all local (I don’t know about you, but the coverage in my paper is….plenty of the incidents above are covered in NY Times and on NY 1) what is the outsider supposed to think, other than, “My God, I don’t envy kids growing up there…what the hell is wrong with the parents in these places”? (On the rare occasion I see coverage of poor whites, I don’t came away with a different sense of the coverage.)

    You’re going have to be more specific on a case where coverage of a missing kid or person was devoted to went out of its way to say, “What a shithole this neighborhood is, no wonder this kid/woman went missing.” I’ve stopped waiting for “missing persons” coverage from TV news; they’re coverage of ongoing investigations are idiotic.

    If the police don’t respond accordingly (and someone else above mentioned an important factor…if the office for missing persons/runaways in in a poorer and/or “ethnic” precinct has three times the volume of cases found in a wealthier–not necessarily whiter–precinct–how effective will the response be?), that’s a problem with society. If a neighborhoods’ residents are eating one another alive–white, black, Native American, whatever–in the short term, is that that totally the media’s fault?

    (To be fair, yes, it is if that victim is lucky enough to have a loud “cheerleading squad” –family and friends willing to help with the investigation–who beg for help, and nobody offers a hand and lends a voice. One case that comes to mind is the torture/murder of Ramona Moore; her mother is suing the city.)

    This is my point–I don’t expect anything from the media. I don’t think the mainstream media coverage means much unless it puts public pressure on the police; I don’t think an “audience” who actually cares about missing kids or violence (or the way its ignored in popular culture) will rely on national TV coverage for information, or even local coverage (sometimes that’s all you can get). I don’t expect national coverage of many missing persons, even in cases where local coverage is NOT enough. And regarding the sneering nature of media coverage of ethnic victims–if 100 children go missing or are sexually assaulted in the course of 5 months in a neighborhood in the South side or Camden or Newark….how can the audience come away without feeling that community– if not ALL poor black/white/Hispanic people–”is crazy?”

  63. Emmy wrote:

    I am a little confused about the statistics cited in the this essay; perhaps there was a detail left out or that I missed but could someone clarify the nationality of the missing children? The essay says,”according to the FBI, the National Center of Missing and Exploited Children and other orgs, most of missing children (those under 18) in America are neither white nor female. In fact 33% of all missing children under 18 are African American girls; overall, it’s believed that Black, Hispanic and Asian Americans account for over 40% of all missing children under 18. ” My question is, if 40% (or thereabouts) of missing children are Black, Hispanic, and Asian American, what ethnicity are the other 60%? If the most common ethnic choices are Black (Af Am), Hispanic, Asian (As Am Pac Is), and White, which ethnicities are contained in the 60% , in addition to White?

    I am not trying to be an asshole here, I really am confused. And I have had enough experience with statistics to know that they can be slippery and that I don’t know enough about them or how to interprete what is shown and what is not shown by them. I hope someone on this site can clarify this passage for me. Thanks

  64. RoslynHolcomb wrote:

    I’ve got another slant on this issue. Last year we had a case in Huntsville AL with a little six year old boy who was kidnapped when someone stole his mother’s car when she went in to pay for gas. The local media covered this in an exemplary fashion. The Amber Alert was put on the tv screen and his picture was kept up for the whole day. Law enforcement was on the case. You could hear the helicopters overhead as they searched for this child.

    People held prayer vigils and searched. You can imagine my dismay when it was discovered that the mother’s boyfriend killed the boy and they came up with the kidnapping story as a cover. Of course I was angry because they’d killed that baby in the first place, but I must say I was also frustrated because I have to wonder what will happen the next time a child is kidnapped. Will the media hesitate because they’ve been burned once?

    I don’t know of any cases in my area where there was any media disparity in a missing child case, though I’m sure there might be some.

  65. Black Canseco wrote:

    Roslynd,

    Remember Susan Smith? She was a white woman who told everyone that a black man carjacked her and stole her car with her two kids in ‘em. Turned she drowned her kids in a nearby lake.

    Remember the Runaway Bride in Georgia? She told everyone she’d been kidnapped by a “Native American and a Mexican and white lady” (swear to God!). Turned out she just ran away because she didn’t wanna get married.

    Even Nancy Grace’s current fixation on little Caylee Anthony. The mom claimed that a Mexican nanny stole her kid. Turns out the Mexican Nanny didn’t exist; but they’re still looking for the child.

    Remember Natalee Holloway in Aruba? They claimed 2 black security guards snatched her. Turned out that was a lie. the media spent like 2 years on that case.

    Madalien McCann’s nice white anglo brit family claimed she was abducted by some Portugese slavery ring people… No evidence of that and yet people looked and looked and looked…

    There are frauds, copycats, accidentally misinformed outlets in every case that garners attention. But no one’s gonna stop looking for white girls/women just because some turned out the be false alarms or victims of domestic violence, etc.

    Media and law enforcement get frustrated, but they keep looking. And if the kid looks like their children, they’re gonna look even more.

    It’s still about who’s valued enough to deserve safety. That’s the key to crime prevention in general and ending child abductions specifically.

  66. Jaye wrote:

    Not to be presumptuous about what you have or haven’t done…but thought I’d throw my ideas out there just in case. I think having a focused campaign on the people who make the decisions on who to cover would be a good starting point. It’s a problem that people have become aware of, I watched an episode of Without a Trace devoted specifically to this issue, I’m guessing it might have been the subject of other shows I haven’t watched. Jon Stewart makes references to how obsessed the media are with “missing white women” constantly on his show. So it’s not like something people don’t realize, which makes it a really opportune time for a campaign.

    People like Abrams, Olbermann, in my mind, are political junkies. They cover missing kids only after the story was created somewhere else, I don’t see them personally making decisions about who to cover, because it’s just not the kind of news they do. O’Reilly and anyone at Fox you can basically write off, they’ll never help. Someone like Nancy Grace would be a better “target” because she seems like a person who actually personally makes decisions about which children/people she is going to broadcast on her show. I don’t watch her very often, so I can’t really attest to her character, but if she is serious about finding people and she actually does care, it may be subconscious racism. She does things the way it has always been done. I know that she credits Johnny Cochrane as a mentor, I don’t think she would want to be branded as a racist. If she does care…she seems like a good person to target for awareness. If she only cares about ratings, she seems like a good target to be shamed into covering more missing children of color.

    I also think having a sort of resource website where parents of missing children of color can go for how to deal with a racist media, or a racist police force. I’m sure that these parents have gone through similar experiences, and faced the same old story from the police, media, etc., and some have probably been more successful than others. To hear what other parents have gone through so that new parents of missing children of color will learn what not to do, what to expect, have a place of support, and build on the methods of parents of color who have been successful about getting their kid out to media outlets and taken seriously by the police. Most of the time when we hear about a parent of color not being taken seriously by media or police, we don’t hear the precise details, what exactly was said, how exactly they were treated, what precise excuses they were given…were they dismissed, were their calls ignored, were they passed off to different departments? Knowing what to expect, when not to waste their time, knowing what to say, who is the best person to talk to, and just knowing that they are not alone or crazy in the way they are being treated.
    If there is already a site like this, just ignore me.

  67. TwennyTwo wrote:

    peace,

    I’d like to post these ads in my sidebar- do you have something I can cut and paste into my template?

    This is personal; that child could be me. Also because, I had a friend who was abducted and killed as an adult- and I still think she got a lot of Nancy Grace and national coverage because people thought she was white (actually, Latina).

    Please let me know if you have that template.

    peace
    TwennyTwo

  68. Persia wrote:

    Thanks so much for this. We recently lost a (white) girl in our community to murder– our state’s first and only Amber Alert– and the anguish all communities feel when one of their own is lost should be recognized.

  69. Yvette wrote:

    Remember Susan Smith? She was a white woman who told everyone that a black man carjacked her and stole her car with her two kids in ‘em. Turned she drowned her kids in a nearby lake…

    As long as we’re remembering: Remember Charles Stuart in Boston, who claimed a Black man abducted him and his very pregnant wife while they were at a stoplight, then murdered his woman? Turns out he shot his own wife (and himself) and had his brother help him dispose of the evidence.

    The aftermath in the city was terrible: Black men from a wide age range rounded up and searched, cries for the death penalty for the “monster” that did it, visits to the family from the mayor. And of course, a smaller story about a Black family with a murder victim who asked why they did not receive a mayorial visit…

  70. Yvette wrote:

    (Above should read either “his wife” or “the woman”–not “his woman” LOL)

  71. Black Canseco wrote:

    Yvette,

    I kinda remember the Charles Stuart case. it got some attention in Chicago… Add that loser to the list. It sucks whenever that stuff happens.

    TwentyTwo–there’s code you can cut and paste into blog sidebars, etc in the photobucket folders. I’m gonna add some templates to fresh ads when i do those up in a few days.

  72. heyhey wrote:

    @BlackCansecco : How can we contact you if we want to volunteer to design more online flyers/banner ads for the campaign? I tried looking for contact info on your site but couldn’t find it.

  73. chanita wrote:

    it wouldn’t matter if they posted the pictures of our kids. we all look alike to them anyway, right? ::rolls eyes::

  74. Because We Matter wrote:

    This stuff makes me cry. Seriously.

    As a young biracial woman, I live in an extremely unsafe environment. I know that because I am not white (although I *sort of* look it), I would not be “newsworthy” should I vanish.

    It hurts me deeply to know the evil that lives in this world. All human beings are potential victims of sadistic sociopaths that prey on others. What bothers me, like it bothers all of you, is the way the safety of minority children seems to be a non-issue.

    It infuriates and saddens me beyond belief. No offense to anyone, but I’m sick to death of hearing about Natalee Holloway and her ilk.
    What makes a so-called “beautiful” white blonde special, anyway?

    Or more worthwhile than her “ethnic” counterparts? I’ve never understood this. Anyone who does not see the racism in this is delusional. All I see and hear about is white girl, white girl, white girl.

    Newsflash: we “minorities” are people, too. We matter to somebody somewhere.
    A young white female is NOT and will NEVER be worth more than anyone else in my book. She is equal to all others, not above or below. Unfortunately, this is the way the world works…America has always been this way. The world seems to revolve around white women because they are supposedly “special” and “prettier” than those of us who happen to be of different backgrounds.

    White women have always been viewed as worthy of love, concern, and protection. Most women who are considered “non-white” (including myself) are seen as undeserving of these things.
    I never understood why so many minority women in America seemed so angry when I was growing up. Now I do.

    There’s the blonde news anchor, Ann Pressly, who was found dead the other day. People are having a field day with that one…esp. since the suspected murderer is a black man named Curtis Vance.
    I feel tremendous sympathy for Ann and her parents, but once more, this really isn’t news. It is the same old story over and over. She was simply another young, bubbly white girl with the requisite blonde hair and cheerful “all-American” smile.

    Now Caylee Anthony’s remains have been found. It is OBVIOUS that her mother is guilty as sin. My focus this time is not merely on the fact that the little girl is/was Caucasian and the media spent so much time talking about her. What bothers me is the fact that her mother had clearly committed a crime and despite the lack of a body (at that time), there was tons of evidence to prove that she was guilty.
    I’ve heard people describe Casey Anthony, the mother of the murdered child, as “sexy” and “beautiful”. My husband is a white man and even he is uncomfortable with the obvious disparity in the way these things are handled.

    Had it been a minority woman who had killed and then callously disposed of her kid while living it up, would people be calling her “beautiful”? Would she still be allowed to continue partying despite the photos of her that surfaced following her daughter’s disappearance? Nope. To many people, there would be no problem with a little black/biracial/Asian girl being killed because she’s “nothing special” anyway.

    Just like Debra Lafave, the blond former teacher convicted of having sex with a student, was deemed “too beautiful” to go to jail. I can talk all day about this.
    If it’s white, female, and most of all BLONDE…it’s a big deal.

    If it’s nappy or “non-white”…who the hell cares? That seems to be the attitude.

  75. Shelia Bradley-Smith wrote:

    Experiencing first hand how cruel the media can be is the reason I started a petition for equal coverage for all missing children. I appreciate the coverage my nieces have gotten, however that is not enough. They have a twenty four hour weather channel and late night poker on all night, why the hell aren’t these missing children on at the least somewhere on these channels. Personally, I am tired of hearing about who or what celebrity had a child or who was drunk in Hollywood. Our children are being stolen, raped, and murdered and the media only cares about crap. I am also paying for these cable packages($100.00) and not be able to demand what I want to watch. I am paying, so I should be able to watch a missing kids channel all night if I choose. I appreciate this site even mentioning my nieces but we need more. Sometimes I get so angry at this mess; I just feel like saying forget it. I can’t and I won’t ever stop looking for Diamond and Tionda. I have become so bitter about the unequal treatment of our black, hispanic, asian, and other minority children being ignored, I sometimes ignore any amber alerts. Then I have to remind myself that it’s not the child’s fault. What these corporate owners don’t realize is that if they fail to keep ours in the news, how long will it be before a sexual predator steals their child(ren). Not putting all children on the air only enables some other child to be stolen. I am sure the sex offenders appreciate the media not airing missing children. That gives them time to move around hunting for a child to prey on. I am planning to have a “blackout” day simply turn off our televisions just for one day. Then perhaps the media will feel the pain as their neilsen ratings hit the bottom. I thank you again for allowing my nieces to be featured here and please sign the petition.