Quoted: Melissa Harris Lacewell on Malcolm X

Excerpted from “Happy Birthday, Malcolm”, originally published at The Root.


Many of our modern leaders live by cynical double standards. They practice slippery personal ethics, while lecturing the masses about morality. They consume conspicuously, while telling ordinary folks to save their pennies. They father children outside of marriage, then blame single mothers for the violence in black communities. They blame individuals for their circumstances, rather than help them deconstruct, understand and overcome the historical, structural, political, reasons for their plight.

Malcolm taught us better. He criticized the powerful rather than the powerless. He pointed to the pathologies of the privileged instead of the failings of the oppressed. His own story of redemption was emblematic of the possibilities available to even the most disempowered, but when he pointed to solutions, they were consistently collective.

Fulfilling his religious responsibility of Hajj, Malcolm discovered that the United States looked very different when viewed from the other side of the Atlantic. Living abroad altered his understanding of race, politics and power. Worshipping in Mecca and living in Accra, he came to understand himself and black America as part of a larger, global struggle for human rights. That sort of world view is crucially important now, in an era in which the United States’ domestic and foreign policy has become woefully narrow.

Early in his public career, a young white woman approached Malcolm and asked him what role sincere white allies could have in the struggle for racial equality. He rebuffed her and told her that there was no role for whites at all. Years later, he said he regretted his response and spoke of the difficulty in building workable interracial coalitions. He remained committed to black empowerment and self-governance within African-American organizations, but toward the end of his life he also came to understand the critical importance of anti-racist efforts among white Americans. He taught us that we must acknowledge human interdependence if we hope to build enduring movements out of the fragile and complicated interests that we share.

—-

More information on Malcolm X:


The Wikipedia Enty

Speech: The Ballot or the Bullet

Collected Audio Speeches

The Malcolm X Project at Columbia University

Latoya’s Note: The Autobiography of Malcolm X is one of the defining books in my life. The first time I read it, I was nine. Even now, though I haven’t picked it up in about five years, I can still remember whole passages by heart, and the basic wording of much more. What I find interesting is that as I grew older, my interpretation and understanding of the book changed. When I was younger, I was enthralled by ex-criminal, black nationalist Malcolm X; as I got older I began to wonder more about his transformation to El-Hajj Malik El-Shabazz, his journey to Mecca, and his change in mindset and focus. It is his journey that inspires my own.

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. Happy Birthday to El-Hajj Malik El-Shabazz « The Mustard Seed on 21 May 2008 at 7:17 am

    […] blogs: The Autobiography of Malcolm X is one of the defining books in my life. The first time I read it, […]

Comments

  1. Ms. Four wrote:

    Latoya, this is a lovely piece. Thanks for sharing it. A question: maybe I read your note too literally… are you Muslim or converting to Islam?

  2. Latoya Peterson wrote:

    LOL! Let me clarify - I am talking about my mental journey, not my spiritual one. I’m actually not affiliated with any one religion, though I lean toward Christianity.

  3. Jus Plain Ol Me wrote:

    You read that book at 9?! WOW. I was still tinkering around with Nancy Drew, the Hardy Boys and Choose Your Own Adventure.

    Note to self: give my 8-month old daughter eight years to finish the Autobiography of Malcolm X.

    / hoping I don’t become THAT parent

  4. Latoya Peterson wrote:

    I was too, but Mom started my deprogramming early. They gave me the story of Othello around age nine or ten as well, if I remember correctly.

    LOL, let the kid relax. There are benefits to the early awareness, but there are a lot of bad parts to it as well. I got in a lot of trouble in middle school for challenging historical ideas and refusing to stand for the pledge. And again, there are benefits and drawbacks to being That parent as well.

  5. Lyonside wrote:

    >LOL, let the kid relax. There are benefits to the early awareness, but there are a lot of bad parts to it as well.

    Heh - this hit home a bit (although for me it was Mary Shelly’s Frankenstein in 3rd grade, courtesy of a nun who knew I was bored). Personal opinion: Choose the middle ground - have the books available and in a common room, not necessarily on the grown-up bookshelf, and let the kids find their own way based on interest and reading level. My goal is to have an open bookshelf: if I have problems with any part of the content on my shelves or with answering questions about them, then it probably shouldn’t be on there in the first place.

  6. Manju wrote:

    “They blame individuals for their circumstances, rather than help them deconstruct, understand and overcome the historical, structural, political, reasons for their plight.

    Malcolm taught us better. He criticized the powerful rather than the powerless. He pointed to the pathologies of the privileged instead of the failings of the oppressed.”

    This is a problematic reading of Malcolm X, and strikes me as an attempt to make him more palpatable to traditional leftist thinkers. I don’t think malcom saw it as a mutually exclusive either/or game. he criticized the powerless as well as the powerful. he pointed out the “pathologies of the priviged” while concentrating on the “failings of the oppressed.”

    in fact, especially early on, he concentrated on what the oppressed could do to free themselves, and was less concerned with white society changing. ergo, the separatism and the embrace of entrepreneurship and (although not explicit) free-market principles. He did not want to beg the white man for acceptance.

    Ironically, it was the Jewish community, that followed this MO to perfection: teaching their children about their oppression but allowing no excuse for failure, especially in free-market America. Many of the banks that dominate the street today, especially Goldman Sachs, started out in part as a response to the fact that Jews where not allowed to take make partner at the top white shoe banks, especially the House of Morgan. Oh, how times have changed.

  7. Abu Sinan wrote:

    I didnt read the autobiography until years after I converted to Islam. It was a good read and his life is an inspiration.

    I am white, but his life almost seems to have mirrored my own to a certain extent.

    May God have mercy on his soul.

  8. Arturo wrote:

    You should’ve seen the look I got from my 12th grade AP English teacher when I tried to submit the Autobiography as my senior book report.

  9. YamYam wrote:

    Even though I wasn’t born Black in the United States his story resonates for all those who in some way share his culture, which he styled from the blend of resistance, affirmation and dignity that his life shone light on. Reading the Autobiography of Malcolm X opened up something inside me which no one else had ever really talked about. It is something grinding right now in the axis of America, and being a person of darker skin that goes through life in the United States relearning his identity in a sense, the memories of Malcolm’s words and feelings create an influence that was always meant to be heeded.

    I always think of the words eulogized in his name “black shining prince,” with light in mind.

  10. Kai wrote:

    Latoya, yes, Malcolm has also been a central pivot in my own journey too, and I know what you mean about changing as time wears on. Your readings and understandings evolve and grow as you do. And I’d offer that the best writings continually change throughout your life, because they’re alive with you, they are not received intact but are absorbed bit by bit, and your interpretations are alive, the emphasis or orientation or focus is alive, it all keeps shifting before you because you yourself are a non-static shifting entity. When you know what you know and it’s unchanging, you’ve stopped growing. So keep on growing. Peace.

  11. Safiya Outlines wrote:

    Thank you for choosing such a beautiful photograph of him to accompany this post.

  12. G.K. wrote:

    Another weird coincidence—I just watched DEATH OF A PROPHET, a pretty good 1981 film that centers on Malcolm’s last days (featuring a young then-unknown Morgan Freeman as the Minister, showing even back then that he had a mad strong star presence) last night. Also watched a 2005 doc called THE ASSASSINATION OF MALCOLM X less than a month ago.

    I myself read THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF MALCOLM X when I was 12, as well as THE BLACK PANTHERS, BLACK BOY, UNCLE TOM’S CHILDREN (yup, I was once a little Richard Wright-reading fiend) as well as DIE,N——,DIE! by H. Rap Brown. I got into radical reading at a young age ( my mother got me the first 3 books, I got the 4th). Now that I look back on it, I was a little young for some of those subjects, but I got radicalized at a young age nevertheless.

    My boyfriend also said that reading MALCOLM X was a major turning point in his life (even though that happened at a much later age). I liked the Spike Lee film, but felt that it really didn’t reach deep beneath the surface to show the real Malcolm beyond the mythical media image of him. Come to think of it, I just checked out a book collection of some of his last speeches. Anyway, I like Ms. Lacewell’s blog, and it’s always nice to see Brother X still getting mad props for the legacy he left and the fact that soem of his words are still relevant in the here and now to a lot of folk.

    Here’s DEATH OF A PROPHET at IMDB:

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0179757/

  13. T.H. wrote:

    Another weird coincidence—I just watched DEATH OF A PROPHET, a pretty good 1981 film that centers on Malcolm’s last days (featuring a young then-unknown Morgan Freeman as the Minister, showing even back then that he had a mad strong star presence) last night. Also watched a 2005 doc called THE ASSASSINATION OF MALCOLM X less than a month ago.

    I myself read THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF MALCOLM X when I was 12, as well as THE BLACK PANTHERS, BLACK BOY, UNCLE TOM’S CHILDREN (yup, I was once a little Richard Wright-reading fiend) as well as DIE,N——,DIE! by H. Rap Brown. I got into radical reading at a young age ( my mother got me the first 3 books, I got the 4th). Now that I look back on it, I was a little young for some of those subjects, but I got radicalized at a young age nevertheless.

    My boyfriend also said that reading MALCOLM X was a major turning point in his life (even though that happened at a much later age). I liked the Spike Lee film, but felt that it really didn’t reach deep beneath the surface to show the real Malcolm beyond the mythical media image of him. Come to think of it, I just checked out a book collection of some of his last speeches. Anyway, I like Ms. Lacewell’s blog, and it’s always nice to see Brother X still getting mad props for the legacy he left and the fact that soem of his words are still relevant in the here and now to a lot of folk.

    Here’s DEATH OF A PROPHET at IMDB:

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0179757/

  14. m.dot wrote:

    Love,

    You ain’t have to tell me that you remember whole passages by heart.

    I could sense the passion in your opening lines.

    This piece goes hard.

    Paul Pierce hard in the paint, hard.

    Thank you for writing and sharing it.

  15. Persia wrote:

    Such an amazing book. It’s been on my bookshelf since I read it, though I haven’t re-read in years. I read it when I was older than you, LaToya, though not by much. I wonder what would grab my attention now.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.