Immigration Game Attacked, Publisher Fires Back

Originally published by the GamePolitics blog

In recent months, GamePolitics has been tracking the development of ICED [I Can End Deportation], a serious game designed to publicize the issues faced by immigrants in the United States. The final version launched earlier this month.

Published by human rights organization Breakthrough, ICED examines immigration issues from the perspective of the immigrant. This is, of course, a hot-button political issue these days, so it’s not surprising that ICED has generated some controversy.

An article on Alex Jones’ InfoWars trashes ICED, terming it “an illegal immigration training game:”

An Indian woman, Mallika Dutt, has released a video game that essentially trains illegal aliens how to sneak across the border and avoid border patrol agents and cops…

For the casual observer, Ms. Dutt comes off as your garden variety liberal “human rights” advocate with a useful penchant for technology. But it is a bit more sinister than that…

As the average Mexican or Latin American does not have access to a video game console, let alone a television, the game is more practically geared toward an effort to inculcate middle class Americans into the belief that illegal immigration is a human rights issue, never mind open borders and the influx of third world people is a globalist plot to turn the United States, soon to become part of a North American Union, into a feudal slave labor gulag based on the China model. It has absolutely nothing to do with human rights.

Asked by GamePolitics to comment on the harsh criticism, Breakthrough’s Mallika Dutt pulled no punches in her response:

ICED – I Can End Deportation is a video game about the lack of due process in the immigration system as it applies to legal permanent residents, asylum seekers and people who are here on valid visas – it’s not about illegal immigrants – as anyone who’s actually bothered to play the game would quickly realize.

One of the characters, Marc, is a war veteran – and many vets, who have legal resident status, have been deported because of unfair immigration laws. Current detention and deportation laws hold people, even legal residents, in detention indefinitely with no access to a judge. Legal residents can be deported for minor crimes – without the opportunity to make a case before a judge.

It’s interesting that those who claim to be supporting the American way of life, are the very ones who are ripping apart due process and fairness in our legal systems…

GP: The immigration issue is surely a controversial one, and there are valid points to be made on both sides. But, frankly, the InfoWars piece smacks of prejudice and stereotyping.

Making it a point to identify Mallika Dutt as “an Indian woman” and asserting that “the average Mexican or Latin American does not have access to a video game console” pretty much show where the article is coming from.

And, note to InfoWars: ICED is not played on a console or a television. It’s a PC game.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • NewsVine
  • Current
  • email
  • Print

Comments

  1. Nadra wrote:

    In addition to the point about the average Mexican or Latin American not having access to a video game console being problematic, the assumption that Latin Americans exclusively make up the undocumented population is problematic. What about undocumented Asians, Europeans, Africans or, even, Canadians, who really do make up a significant portion of the undocumented population in the U.S. When is undocumented immigration going to stop being painted as a Latin thing?

  2. J-fro wrote:

    another wonderful example of when journalists do not do enough background research. I wonder if these people have been reading about Maxim mag’s current problem of reviewing CDs (negatively) even before they come out…or in one case, before the album was even finished!

    and btw, some Americans are very quick to condemn immigration while somewhere down the line one of their ancestors immigrated to America, too.

  3. Phrone wrote:

    There is nothing in that excerpt from InfoWars that can be taken as serious, thoughtful commentary. America as soon to be “part of the North American Union”? “A feudal slave labor gulag based on the China model”? And just from skimming over the article itself, the equation that problems with immigration services to being illegal and the talk of conspiracy doesn’t suggest that the whole article is much better.

  4. meep wrote:

    Following jones’s logic, can we safely assume that games like GTA are meant to both “train” people how to steal cars and murder sex workers and then “inculcate middle class Americans into the belief that” car theft and murder are A-OK?

  5. theruffian wrote:

    “And, note to InfoWars: ICED is not played on a console or a television. It’s a PC game. ” -

    Ha!

  6. al wrote:

    why this is hysterical: if this game trains people to be better illegal aliens, what does grand theft auto teach us?

  7. Dan wrote:

    “And, note to InfoWars: ICED is not played on a console or a television. It’s a PC game.”

    But surely that only strengthens their point. I mean, those damned Spaniards couldn’t possibly be smart enough to use a computer, amirite?!

  8. DivergentDana wrote:

    “As the average Mexican or Latin American does not have access to a video game console, let alone a television”

    I bet good money they’re going to get chewed out for that one by readers, and deservedly so.