What Does Kwanzaa Mean To Us?

by Racialicious Special Correspondent Latoya Peterson

Going through my normal morning blog reading ritual, I came across a link to an article on the declining popularity of Kwanzaa.

The article begins:

When I first learned about Kwanzaa in the 1980s, I questioned the need to create an observance for African Americans. It felt too contrived: all those symbols and paraphernalia, all that ritual. Even the Swahili names for the seven days of the holiday rang false: Swahili is an East African language, and the majority of African Americans have origins in West Africa.

Still, the holiday caught on; Kwanzaa cards and wrapping paper lie on the shelves next to supplies for Hanukkah and Christmas. There is a Kwanzaa postage stamp, and each year, President Bush issues a Kwanzaa message. I’ve grown to appreciate Kwanzaa because I’ve seen how it unites disparate, even hostile, segments of the African American community.

These days, though, I fear for the future of Kwanzaa. The latest figures, from a 2004 study by the National Retail Foundation, say that just 13 percent of African Americans observe the holiday. When I go to Kwanzaa ceremonies, the audience is mostly folks in their 40s and older. I don’t see the younger people, the ones who need to embrace Kwanzaa and keep it vibrant.

When they look at Kwanzaa, do they see a relic from the ’60s?

Interesting question.

(For those of you not familiar with the specifics of Kwanzaa, please go and read the article. Before we continue, I need everyone to understand that Kwanzaa is NOT a substitute for Christmas.)

Kwanzaa is a strange holiday and it is still seen as not quite legitimate. After all, it is a cultural holiday in a season of religious based holidays. In some ways, Kwanzaa is kind of a relic from the 60s. That was back when African-Americans were struggling to form a national identity and show solidarity and that led to some of the pan-African celebrations and customs the community has embraced.

Now, many African-Americans are comfortable with their identity and have focused more on their individual lives. Kwanzaa is more of an after thought.

I was raised with Kwanzaa when I was younger. Every year, Mom broke out the kente cloth table mats, the ear of corn, the wooden chalice thing she bought from the black expo, our wooden carved kinara and the red, black, and green candles. We celebrated Kwanzaa every year for about five years.

As my sister and I entered adolescence our enthusiasm for the holiday waned. After a while, we stopped formally celebrating Kwanzaa.

(Though, I must mention that we were subject to random pop quizzes. “Spell kujichagulia and tell me what it stands for!”)

As an adult, I don’t celebrate Kwanzaa. (I also have yet to find enough Christmas spirit to decorate my studio.)

That will change in a few years though, when I have children.

You see, Kwanzaa is very useful in helping children to understand their identity, to know who they are. The discussion of the Nguzo Saba is actually an excellent springboard into conversations about identity, community, responsibility, and purpose. Even if a child doesn’t think about Kwanzaa at all for the other 51 weeks each year, the lessons of Kwanzaa will remain with them.

I learned to understand umoja (unity) which is why I feel a strong call to serve my community.

I learned about kujichagulia (self-determination) which inspires me to keep pushing toward my goals and making my dreams into a reality.

I try to practice ujima (collective work and responsibility) which means I will go out and support my community in various ways. This is mainly financial (seeking out black owned businesses) but will later expand to being a mentor and a foster parent.

Becoming a business owner and networking with other black professionals allows me to employ the principle of ujamaa (cooperative economics).

My entire life is dedicated to nia (purpose). Why am I here? What am I supposed to do to improve my community? What is my role?

Learning to use your skills to benefit your community is a practical application of kuumba (creativity). Encouraging others to tap into their creative self is also important to me.

Believing in others and believing in ourselves is the cornerstone of imani (faith). Imani is the final principle, used on the final day of Kwanzaa. And then your new year begins allowing you the opportunity to put these principles into practice.

Kwanzaa is a holiday that allows you to reconnect with yourself and your community. It allows for understanding and it encourages reflection.

Does anyone else celebrate Kwanzaa? What are your impressions of the holiday?

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. When Is the “Right” Time? « Aaminah Hernández on 03 Jan 2008 at 12:52 pm

    […] “special” earlier in their lives. This curiosity of mine was piqued when I read a post elsewhere about Kwanzaa and the author said that they were waiting to have kids to celebrate because they want to make it […]

Comments

  1. Bianca wrote:

    I attended a Kwanzaa celebration last week and noticed that the majority of the audience was the bourgeois Black set, in their mid 4os and older. I went to hear Dr. Karenga speak. As I walked around, I heard many speak often of “the movement” (Black Power?) and ask about the whereabouts of the Black youth. One older man greeted me with “Habari gani!” and when I didn’t respond with “Kujichagulia!” (I said, “Um… hi!”) a look of major disappointment spread across his face.
    “This is Bed-Stuy, where are all the Black teens?” one woman asked. I thought “At home enjoying their Christmas presents.” I left before Dr. Karenga came on.

    As someone whose parents both tried to adopt Kwanzaa in the holiday season, but never really caught the spirit of the holiday, I didn’t have a strong foundation for it at home. When I was in school, Kwanzaa was never discussed. White kids would ask if I celebrated it. I would shake my head no and remind them “not all Black people do that.”
    I moved away, met folks at college who were “into” it, read up on it, but I never fully accepted it.
    Last year, I discussed the festival with my students, taught them the words and the meanings and showed them the ways in which they already practiced these principles, just to keep them aware of it. But I wasn’t surprised or offended by their lack of interest. This year, right or wrong, I didn’t bother. Younger people are removed not only from African traditions but also increasingly from the freedom/liberation/empowerment movements of older generations. It’s interesting and meaningful to present it in the context of an alternative to ConsumerChristmas, but that discussion is a long & hard one with the kids who rock new sneakers and jeans and electronics on a monthly basis. At the end of the day, it wasn’t a priority.
    On a personal level, I’m fine with doing the best I can at all times, trying to honor my community and myself. I would feel very ridiculous lighting candles and wearing sashes and crowns.
    At work, I see Kwanzaa is approached the way Hanukah or the Chinese New Year are when I was in school: look at this celebration, look at the funny clothes, hear the funny words, too bad it’s not as fun as Christmas!

  2. ebog/gary wrote:

    It’s hard for me to separate Kwanza from its founder, Ron Karenga, who was (in no particular order) a cult leader, FBI informant (he informed on LA’s Black Panther chapter) and a convicted torturer who kidnapped and abused two female members of his “United Slaves” organization in 1971, this because he thought they were putting “crystals” in his food.

    From the May 1971 LA Times: “Deborah Jones, who once was given the Swahili title of an African queen, said she and Gail Davis were whipped with an electrical cord and beaten with a karate baton after being ordered to remove their clothes. She testified that a hot soldering iron was placed in Ms. Davis’s mouth and placed against Ms. Davis’s face and that one of her own big toes was tightened in a vise. Karenga also put detergent and running hoses in their mouths, she said.”

    I guess maybe Kwanza is the like US Constitution: the fact that a bunch of racist slave owners came up with it doesn’t make it all bad, but your remiss in discussing Kwanza without putting it context, which is to say, identifying as the creation a cultish woman abuser who was never above selling his political enemies out to the Feds. Umoja, indeed!

  3. Latoya Peterson wrote:

    Bianca -

    “At work, I see Kwanzaa is approached the way Hanukah or the Chinese New Year are when I was in school: look at this celebration, look at the funny clothes, hear the funny words, too bad it’s not as fun as Christmas!”

    Word. I guess these things depend. In my household, Kwanzaa was fun, a nice reprieve from all the conversations about oppression and mental enslavement.

    However, I should also mention that my mom was not a “joiner” so we would have never came to an event like the one you suffered through. It does seem quite off putting and overeager.

    I also understand why your kids would not be interested - Aaron MacGruder’s comic strips dedicated a lot of ink to Huey’s struggles with trying to embrace Kwanzaa. They are worth a look, regardless of how you feel about the direction that the Boondocks/Aaron MacGruder has gone in since achieving commerical success.

    Ebog -

    Interesting. I don’t really know much about Ron Karenga besides the fact that (1) he started the holiday and (2) there is normally a mention of him in all children’s Kwanzaa books.

    Can you please cite some sources for this information (besides the Times article from the 1970s)? I looked around for criticism of Kwanzaa but the most recent article that came the closest to your criticism was by Ann Coulter. And you know she doesn’t believe in sources.

    That being said, I don’t think that idea is that far-fetched. A lot of ugly deeds were masked during the whole civil rights struggle and some very prominent people had some large skeletons in the closet. But…a few more sources would help. Or if someone would go and update the controversy page on the Wiki…

    That being said, I still like the concept of Kwanzaa and what it attempts to do. Implementation is up to you.

  4. Sister P wrote:

    I haven’t participated in Kwanzaa celebrations in the past. But now as a Black parent who is raising a child in a town where Black people make up only 13% of the population, I want to expose my daughter to anything where there are more than 20 Black people together and there is no collection plate.

    We had the privilege of celebrating the first day of Kwanzaa in Detroit last week and heard poet Jessica Care Moore before hearing Haki Madhubuti and watching youth and adult drummers and dancers. The organizers did a great job of mixing youth and elders and it was a great feeling.

  5. Bianca wrote:

    Latoya,
    Forgive the horrible grammar I used in my earlier post. I know my students are loyal viewers of the Boondocks TV show, but I don’t think they’ve read the strip at all. I have all the Boondocks books somewhere. I guess I should revisit them & have them on hand the next time around. Thank you for that tip.
    Happy New Year!

  6. Tami wrote:

    My family never embraced Kwanzaa, never talked about it at all.

    I became aware of the holiday in college –the time of Public Enemy, Africa medallions and red, black and green wristbands. In my early 20s, I attended a few Kwanzaa celebrations.

    Somehow I could never truly embrace the celebration. Pan-Africanism makes me uncomfortable. It has certainly allowed African Americans to connect with a home and a history, but I think in too many cases it is a false history. Pan-African elements like Kwanzaa have turned richly diverse African peoples and cultures into a monolith in the eyes of too many black Americans. I also think it has obscured the real, sometimes inspiring, sometimes disappointing, histories and cultures of our forebearers.

    I feel all kinds of guilty saying this, but Kwanzaa to me has always felt like a mish-mash of real and imagined African rituals and values designed to make me feel better about being the descendant of slaves.

    Of course, it is so like me to overthink something instead of just going with the flow and enjoying the fellowship. And maybe I’m not fully grasping something about the holiday. Does anyone else feel the way I do?

  7. Ms. Four wrote:

    I’m a white mom of black Ethiopian kids. We celebrate Ethiopian holidays, but I’m wondering if we should be talking about Kwanzaa too. West African heritage is not their heritage, but they are African Americans now. Do they need to know kwanzaa to be part of the community?

  8. Free wrote:

    to make me feel better about being the descendant of slaves.

    Tami, are you ashamed? I am a descendant of slaves and I talk about it wherever I go, and that means all-over-the-world. I am proud of my descent from strong people. It takes a lot of character to fight for independence, own businesses, gain education, and create art all under conditions of oppression. I love my ancestors and take their lessons with me wherever I go.

  9. ebog/gary wrote:

    Latoya writes: Can you please cite some sources for this information (besides the Times article from the 1970s)? I looked around for criticism of Kwanzaa but the most recent article that came the closest to your criticism was by Ann Coulter. And you know she doesn’t believe in sources.

    Thanks, but no thanks on the Coulter. I don’t read her column, so I have no idea what or anything she might have to add to this discussion.

    Because people are uncomfortable about Karenga’s past (you might get thrown in with Coulter if you mention his conviction in most progressive company) the bulk of the citations will require going to the library and spending some time with the microfiche archive. (The trial was a big deal in LA at the times and they covered quite a bit of it.) If that’s too much of a bother, Scot Brown’s “Fighting for US: Maulana Karenga, the US Organization, and Black Cultural Nationalism” (New York University Press, 2003) covers Karenga and the trial at length and may be available on Amazon. Additionally, if you feel like springing for the NYT archive, this 1971 article details Karenga’s arraignment. http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F10A10FC3A5814728FDDA10894D8415B808BF1D3

    Not everyone has time for the library or cash for Amazon, so this free 2006 article in a Colorado paper also discusses the charges: http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4191/is_20061123/ai_n16877774

    One of the difficulties in assessing Karenga is that he and his organization United Slaves (as well as their rival Black Panthers) were under extreme pressure at the time of these events from the FBI and COINTELPRO . Many people are today willing to forgive Karenga’s actions as having been the product of FBI harassment, but I’m not one of them. If you’re interested in a lively discussion of these issues, some of it from correspondents who were there at time, the listserv of the Black Radical Congress contains lots of pro and con takes on Karenga and his importance to the movement.

    http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/45a/292.html

    For the record, though, Ron Karenga, founder of Kwanza, was indeed convicted in 1971 of torturing two members of the US organization, Gail Davis and Deborah Jones. This is Jones’s testimony from the LA Times:

    “[Jones] said that she and Gail Davis were whipped with an electrical cord and beaten with a karate baton after being ordered to remove their clothes. She testified that a hot soldering iron was placed in Ms. Davis’s mouth and placed against Ms. Davis’s face and that one of her own big toes was tightened in a vise. Karenga, head of US, also put detergent and running hoses in their mouths, she said.”

    Ann Coulter didn’t invent those facts (okay, I went and found her article), she’s only manipulating them for her own ends. Two wrongs don’t make a right though, meaning that fighting Coulter’s awful racism shouldn’t involve ignoring this awful (and I would argue damning) chapter from Karenga’s past. Claiming that “the FBI made me do it” is like claiming that “9/11 made me torture.”

  10. Latoya Peterson wrote:

    Sister P - Awesome! I am glad you and your children enjoyed what your city put on. Some of my best memories involve seeing all black dance troupes (though not Alvin Ailey) and the Kennedy Center’s annual Kwanzaa presentation.

    Bianca -

    No sweat, I didn’t even notice. The strip is a lot better than the show, IMO especially the older stuff. If you pick up “A Right to Be Hostile” (collection) you’ll find some of the strips on Huey and Kwanzaa, plus a lot of ones you will appreciate where Huey faces off with the public school system and his teacher’s misguided attempts at diversity.

    Tami - My friend and I actually had that conversation. She and I both see value in Kwanzaa but for different reasons. She is also very wary of pan-Africanism. However, it is a good starting point to immerse yourself in culture.

    Ms. Four - It depends. What do you think your children would get out of it? And what impression do you get from them about their identity? Are they ashamed of their blackness? Do they identify more as African-American or Ethiopian? (Some teens will actually relate more to their cultural heritage than where they grew up). They do not need to know Kwanzaa (see the responses above) but it can be a helpful tool.

    Free -

    Interesting take on Tami’s comment.

    Ebog -

    Awesome. Thank you for taking the time to suss out the sources and provide more information. I’ll make sure to use some of this information in further discussions about Kwanzaa.

  11. Mark La Roi wrote:

    ebog/gary did an excellent job of sourcing the roots of Kwanzaa. Ron Karenga’s ideas aren’t the best on which to form a healthy foundation free of hate. I am black and I don’t celebrate Kwanzaa. The thing is, if I researched my roots to discover where my ancestors lived, I doubt I’d feel any need to start carrying out the rituals which they had observed.

    My self-image is based on today and not who my forebearers were, and while I can understand a tremendous interest in knowing for knowledge’ sake, I just don’t feel the pull to act out something based on a culture I may not have even originated through.

    ‘Course, I am a bit different… ;)

  12. michelle wrote:

    Ebog/Gary,
    Thank you for bringing up the point about Karenga. He is exactly the reason why I have so many problems with Kwanzaa. I actually read the COINTELPRO papers in college and also saw Karenga’s name brought up in many books about the Panthers and other radical black movements in the 60s.

    My other problem with Kwanzaa is what I perceive as a belief in a monolithic and mythical “Africa.”

    While I understand search for a concrete identity beyond one of subjagation and slavery that motivated the 60s style Afro-centrism, I have a real problem with creating a hodgepodge African identity with no real knowledge of the complexities of the various ethnic and tribal identities of that vast continent. Having spoken to Nigerians, Ethiopians, folks from Ghana,etc-I know that “Afro-American” notions of Africa are urksome to many people from the continent.

    Too often I feel that we as people of color having been stripped of so much, can cling to identity in forms that are purely symbolic and highly problematic.

    One can get many of the lessons Kwanzaa professes to teach from their local church, gramma, corner head, or anyone else who has some real ethical and moral standing in their lives.

    If Kwanzaa makes you feel good then fine, but please don’t try force the idea that it provides something beyond a purely symbolic construction of black identity.

  13. patti wrote:

    ebog/gary - this is what I have struggled with this year. My daughters are old enough to participate in the celebration of Kwanzaa, but as I began to look into making the actual celebration meaningful for our multiracial family within the community, I found out about Ron Karenga’s past and I am just having trouble wrapping my head around it all.
    I do remember celebrating Kwanzaa in college and it was a very meaningful statement each night as we gathered to really celebrate and motivate one another. And that is the part that I would want to focus on…….
    Thank you for this discussion.

  14. Ms. Four wrote:

    Latoya, thanks for your response.

    My kids identify very strongly as Ethiopian. We eat Ethiopian food for dinner 2-3 nights/week, we talk about Ethiopia all they time, they have almost daily interactions with at least one adult Ethiopian, and well, yes, we have Ethiopian art and books and clothes in the house. We even had an Ethiopian theme to some Christmas cookies:
    http://egypt4.wordpress.com/2007/12/30/christmas-recap/

    (Okay, that was pretty much making the best of icing disaster, but still…)

    We’re also hoping to get to Ethiopia next winter. Ethiopia is pretty much part of daily lives.

    As for how they feel about themselves as black people–that’s hard for me to figure out right now as they are still pretty young. I just asked my five year old what he thought about his skin, and he told me he’d like to try having orange skin, which I think is pretty typical developmental phase, of wanting purple, blue, etc skin. He also told me that his brother has pretty skin; they’re almost exactly the same skin tone. So I’m hopeful they haven’t gotten too much negative stuff yet. But I might be delusional.

    We live in Egypt and there’s a lot of racism here, but I don’t know if they see it. But when we move back to the US, I hope they can be around more black people.

  15. Angela wrote:

    The closest I’ve ever gotten to Kwanzaa was when I did a report on the holiday for a middle school report. Otherwise, I only make note of it if I see it in print on a calendar or in the news. It doesn’t really have a part of my life or that of my family’s. While I don’t think it’s a “fake” celebration, it does have an air of desperation about it, as though blacks (despite not all coming from the same part or even tribes of the continent of Africa) need some sort of holiday to validate our presence in America.

  16. Jen* wrote:

    I remember when I first learned of Kwanzaa, and I was like - somebody made up a holiday?

    I was in sixth or seventh grade, then, but my feelings haven’t changed much. to echo Tami, it’s always felt like a ‘mishmash’ - elements from several different cultures forced together with some lovely sentiments to make people feel like they have something of their own - even if they did make it up themselves.

    The principles of Kwanzaa are great. I support them all, 100%. But my parents used the entire year and English words to teach me those concepts.

    I don’t have a problem with other people celebrating, and if there were events anywhere near me [like dance/music performances, not necessarily lectures] I’d go. Lighting a candle and putting corn on a mat? Not so much for me.

  17. bdsista wrote:

    I haven’t practiced Kwanzaa for many years since I spend most winter breaks in the Carribbean, but I think its important to separate the principles and the intent of Kwanzaa from Karenga whom I have heard speak in the 1980s and found the experience at his Afro American Cultural center to be very retro, but uplifting and enjoyable. Having gone to HBCUs when I graduated and moved to Atlanta, I spent wonderful times celebrating Kwanzaa with brothers and sisters whom I otherwise would not have come in contact with professionally working at CNN. My college friends took me to a house party where we wore Afrocentric dress like Dashikis and wraps and other things. We danced to live drummers, we prayed and poured libations to our ancestors naming those whom we thanked for paving the way for us today. We prayed and named those who were sick, ill or needed prayer collectively. We brought food and shared it. We played games, some people watched TV in a back room (it was all cool), talked, discussed the principles and shared what they meant to us personally and what our goals would be in the future. Share ideas, inspired, encouraged and lifted one another up. I went to other celebrations that were similar. The young people present got to listen to the discussions and were told stories of their elders. They also shared and were encouraged by those present. Oh, and those present were all different religions as well which was also wonderful. Despite whether it is authentic or not, having our culture wrenched from us by the holocaust of slavery, I felt unified, supported and loved communally. I think this is what Kwanzaa is supposed to be about. Creating those bonds of community in the midst of struggle to deal with racism and all the other isms. I think to dismiss it as being not relevant is a part of why the Black community is disintegrating and falling prey to the commercialism of the holidays. It’s based on being much more intelligent than Santa Claus which is also fake. I take offense as it being described as desparate, or unworthy. I have yet to be invited to spend the holidays with any Africans I know, and think it less ingenuous to try to pick some vague West African tradition to try to follow. At least Kwanzaa has a structure and ritual and is easy to implement. It’s not about constructing your self image as a Black person, its about trying to celebrate some aspect of our heritage in a way that is meaningful and unifying. You can choose to do it or not, but in doing it I think you gain more and your children get to see something different than church. Yes its not authentic but I am not Alex Haley and have no clue about where my people came from other than Africa. I will take what I can and make a good life of it here as did my forebears who came here as slaves and survived. If you feel ridiculous lighting candles and wearing African clothes and trying to learn positive African principles then maybe that says more about your feelings about yourself. As an educator I find young people will follow our example and if they see our passion for unity and community and connecting to our heritage then they will get a sense of how it is important. If you lead, they will follow.

  18. Michelle wrote:

    bdsista-
    As an educator don’t you think it’s empowering to share with your students how many slaves tried to retain aspects of their individual indigenous cultures even while being dehumanized is a greater lesson in self love and pride?

    Gullah/Geechee people and other communities made real efforts to retain their culture in the face of slavery. A great myth about black people who were enslaved in this country is that they were so broken that they retained nothing and resisted nothing.

    There are so many examples of black community and struggle that come right from the pages of reality and history that the need the need to make up a holiday to celebrate things is completely absurd. There are many real stories to tell that celebrate our heritage that don’t need to come with red, black and green candles, fake kente cloth, and dashikis.

    Again, it’s very hard to separate the man from the message. Karenga violated and destroyed the very kind community and struggle that his creation, Kwanzaa, seeks to revive/instill. I’m not sure how that is not problematic and how he it can be so easily dismissed.

    bdsista, I don’t know what you teach or how you teach it, but please let your students know about the efforts of many of our slave ancestors to retain their culture and pass it on.

    Please let them know about the diaspora and how black people enslaved from New Orleans to Brasil and other parts of South America and the Caribbean , tried to hold on to their indigenous forms of religion through the practices of santeria,voodoo, and candomble.

    Please let them know about the Muslim slaves who jumped ship during that vicious cross Atlantic kidnapping and at Igbo Landing and other forms of jihad to battle their forced enslavement.

    If you want a time and a place to celebrate/teach these things, why not pick Juneteenth?

    This post is not an attack on you or your belief in Kwanzaa, but a plee for you as an educator to look to real events in the lives of black people in America to hold up as a way to instill values of self love, community, and struggle in future generations.

  19. bdsista wrote:

    Being of Geechee/Gullah heritage and having family members who struggle to retain their land on Dafuskie Island, I am well aware of all the issues related to slavery and the struggles of our people. I have worked for civil rights organizations and risked jail, and even those whom we honor for paving the way to freedom for us were not without flaws. But I remember a time when wearing an Afro meant something other than a fashion statement, I remember when wearing a dashiki created controversy even within the Black community. I remember when wearing Kente (fake or otherwise) was a political statement. I teach children and adults all of the history that they find unpleasant and difficult to deal with, but I also find that in rituals such as those created by Black Greek organizations and other public service organizations serve a purpose of bonding people together for a united purpose. I can separate Karenga from the good that exists in celebrating Kwanzaa. If we can grow up with the tooth fairy, Santa Claus and Easter Bunny, I think taking time out to discuss and celebrate meaningful African Principles of Living (regardless of WHERE they are from in Africa) is worthwhile. I think at this juncture we can agree to disagree on how we choose to feel about the holiday.

  20. thejoyprincess wrote:

    We didn’t celebrate Kwanzaa at all growing up and my background stems from parents who participated in various black liberation movements. I grew up not taking it seriously and I remain surprised that it has become so mainstream even now.

    All that to say, it remains a turn off to me because it smacks of McAfrican-ism, Black American plug-and-play desperation to force an artificial connection to, as plenty have already stated, a generic, mythical and monolithic “Africa.”

    I have no use for it, but I understand the interest in it

  21. Michelle wrote:

    bdsista,
    I too am of Gullah/Geechee heritage and my relatives were burned out of their homes and their community destroyed. So it is with the most respect and with no wish to offend that I respond to you.

    As I said in the previous post, my post was a plea for you to teach something beyond the confines of commodified/symbolic culture from questionable sources like Kwanzaa.

    I’m glad you do teach “children and adults all of the history that they find unpleasant and difficult to deal with.”

    Thank you sincerely for that.

    To go further, I hope you also teach them that there are stark differences between community based on struggle and community based on commodity.

    Symbols can signify certain beliefs, alliances, etc, but in a consumer culture the symbol is emptied of it’s significance. I see Kwanzaa as a safe, empty consumer, feel good so you won’t have to feel bad, driven tradition just like the Easter Bunny, Santa Claus, and all the rest and that ain’t a good thing.

    Afros, dashikis, etc were symbols of a mentality tied to an larger movement with defined goals and structure. So yes the afro had meaning, but it was a symbol that was only powerful and valid tied to that specific ideology in that time and place.

    There were folk I’m sure back then who would wear Afros and dashikis too as they called up the FBI/CIA on people rocking the same dress/natural hair as they were.

    Hair, kente cloth, Kwanzaa and all those things do not take the place or engender community unity/struggle all on their own. The movements that were attempting to do that Karenga helped destroy and in it’s place, he supplied something that people could rally around without actually disrupting the system in any real way.

    That’s why it feels so comfy for us to lump Kwanzaa in with Santa and all that other jazz consumer culture is so good at replicating and perpetuating.

    (BTW-The tradition of Black Greek systems I have no problem with because it is a tradition rooted in real community building and activism that went well beyond the walls of HBCUs. )

    Furthermore, while it is true as you argue, “even those whom we honor for paving the way to freedom for us were not without flaws,” having simple human flaws and seeking to dismantle and destroy a movement, sell “your own” down the river, torture your own, and then turn around and “create” a “tradition” based on all the principles that you willfully trampled upon are 2 different things.

    Under the logic of “I can separate Karenga from the good that exists in celebrating Kwanzaa” we separate Thomas Jefferson the “visionary” and founding father, from Thomas Jefferson the Indian killing, rapist, slaveholder and claim that those two “distinct” identities did not inform one another.

    Flaws are one thing, but willful destruction and colluding to uphold domination and white supremacy is a whole other ball game.

    Let’s just say that Karenga is not on the field with the Flaw Team.

    All that said, thank you again for being a teacher and for sticking your neck out to make the world a better place.

  22. Gregory A. Butler wrote:

    We never celebrated Kwanzaa growing up (actually, we pretty much stopped celebrating Christmas when I, the youngest child, turned 8, so we didnt’ need to replace/suppliment it with another one of the “commercial holidays”)

    Beyond that, it always seemed to be a “fake Chaunaka” to me - and, having lots of friends who celebrated the “real” Chaunaka (and saw it as a poor substitute for Christmas) it didn’t seem like a worthwhile holiday to have.

    If you have to have a day to spend more money than you have and max out your credit cards to buy your friends and relatives stuff they don’t really need anyway, all in celebration of some ancient foreign mythological character who never existed in the real world, why not stick with the original fake holday, Christmas?

    And, in later years, the whole “McAfricanness” of the day (thank you for that phrase, thejoyprincess!!) really struck me.

    There are over 1,000 different languages in Africa - and Swahili (a language originally developed by Omani Arab SLAVE TRADERS so they could more easily kidnap East Africans for sale in the slave markets of what is now Saudi Arabia) isn’t even from the part of Africa that the ancestors of African Americans came from!

    But, sadly to this day, there are still lots of African Americans who think that all Africans speak the same language and have the same culture.

    Last week, my downstairs neighbor, a real estate agent who is not a dumb guy at all, spoke of having a friend of his translate some document into “African”!!!

    Kwanzaa fits right into that ignorance of the cultural reality of the land that our great great grandparents were kidnapped from.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.