Michael Eric Dyson rocks!

by Carmen Van Kerckhove

I just had to throw a quote from him up here on Racialicious. This is his take on the blame hip hop direction that the Don Imus media circus has taken, from Salon’s Audiofile blog:

So the big point really isn’t to score rap for its vicious sexism — if that were the case the mainstream white media would have been on the bandwagon a long time ago. It is to partially exonerate a racist and bigoted representative of its own ranks, in part to exonerate all those other white journalists who either appeared on his show or stood by in silence while he had his way with whatever vulnerable group he chose to attack that day. The white media has to scapegoat rap now to cleanse its hands of the blood — and to wipe clean its conscience — of the suffering of citizens, like black women, it never cared enough to oppose before Imus put his foot in his mouth. Black women are a footnote — and an afterthought — to the controversy.

Thus, all the hand-wringing and feigned horror over how young black males could ever speak about their women in such hateful tones is the delayed reaction of the partially guilty — not through active discourses of assault as with Imus, but through the passive indifference to the plight of women they didn’t care enough about either to learn their condition or to cry out over it on their airwaves. As we’ve seen in the last week, when white media elites are so inclined, they can use the airwaves to tell stories of black life with far more time and resources in one week than they’re used to spending in a year. If black women matter, they can’t just matter when white men mess up.

It is typical of a media that ignores black life that it also ignores the outrage black folk have felt about rappers spitting invective toward its women since the early ’90s. And it’s equally apparent that the white media has no interest in the fierce debate raging within hip-hop about its future and soul. Hundreds of “conscious” rappers who extol the virtues of black female identity — and who indict the materialism and misogyny of rap — can’t get a word in edgewise on white or black media outlets, from radio to television. There’s a blackout of conscience-driven, racially astute, politically motivated rap that contains progressive gender messages, in large part because such rap also contains poignant and prophetic indictments of white supremacy and social injustice, themes that even ostensibly liberal white media is not ready to hear, air or acknowledge. So it closes the mouths of such progressive artists, with the consequence that the women-hating harangues of hip-hop artists drown out the considerable complexity of conscious artists. It does so with the complicity of the very media machine that now wants to point fingers at only half the equation — the rap artists who pour acid on the heads of black women — while failing to self-critically indict its very participation in this unseemly affair. That is utter and naked hypocrisy.

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. femtique.net » Michael Eric Dyson on Rap Music & the IMUS Incident on 24 Apr 2007 at 12:26 am

    […] from Racialicious. Thanks Carmen! Please pass this to all your friends and help them see the truth. So the big point […]

  2. COSELLOUT: Tellin’ It Like It Is when the “Cosellouts” Won’t » Blog Archive » The Nine Lives of Don Imus: A Study in American Denial on 01 Aug 2007 at 4:30 pm

    […] as a scapegoat or perverted pretext to justify or minimize the behavior of Imus. That would be wrong, dishonest, and hypocrytical. The media’s racial “script-flipping” was not limited to Imus defenses. Journalists from Pat […]

Comments

  1. Leon Wynter wrote:

    The brother can definitely rap, but on this point he does NOT rock. So there’s hypocisy in only getting around to the case against the gangstas after a white guy like Imus screws up. And yes, the public conscience was not especially moved by the efforts of black activists against the misogny and self-hatred in the culture in the past. But please, let’s not trot out the media conspiracy theories (how would he or anyone else know about such campaigns in the past? Or about the sturggling “conscience-driven, racially astute…” rappers.)
    What’s the point? Whether or not the “white media” cares about the debate is not the issue. Even Al Sharpton cares–I know because I read it in the “white media”.
    Brothers and sisters, let us NOT allow the perfect to become the enemy of a good we so desparately need. Don’t be distracted by the erudite hype; focus on the cause and settle the petty scores of past media sins later.

  2. Y. Carrington wrote:

    But please, let’s not trot out the media conspiracy theories (how would he or anyone else know about such campaigns in the past?

    Leon, we know because we were there. I was a teenager when Black community groups were protesting against gangsta rap. In fact, many of these actions (like the public smashing of thousands of compact discs by angry protestors) did manage to get some press coverage, but in the passage of time the media has invisibilized this activism. The mainstream media buries people’s history all the time, and has done so since the beginning of this country. Neither Dyson nor anyone has called this a “conspiracy,” because this isn’t a conspiracy.

    Americans lie to ourselves and the world about our history. That is what we’re all taught to do. And as along as we keep lying to ourselves, we will always struggle with racism.

  3. wendi wrote:

    i agree with dyson in his points, and it’s unfortunate that more conscious rap is not highlighted by the mainstream media or supported by record executives. HOWEVER, we as consumers are responsible as well. people can do their own research and look for music that is not played on the radio. i do it myself all the time. but many choose not to. maybe this is one part of the problem. another part of the problem, in my opinion, is our focus on who is blaming whom. i agree with dyson that the focus on black mainstream hip hop artists as the perpetuators of sexism toward black women is a diversion tactic, BUT i don’t really care. i think this provides a perfect opportunity to tackle the problems in hip hop. black people-common folk, activists, politicians, and feminists alike–have been complaining about the sexist and racist aspects of hip hop for years and have not found adequate media support. now that we have it, we are criticizing the media for being too hard on black men involved in mainstream hip hop. i think this is the time for us to seize what the media has given us, whether or not their motives come from the place we want them to, and run with it. it reminds me somewhat of the abolition debates–some wanted to end slavery for economic reasons, other for humanitarian reasons, but in the long run, even if their intentions differed, the end result they sought was the same-the end of slavery. so maybe we should take this as a lesson–tackle the problem now, avoiding division among the ranks, then address the motivation after the battle’s been won.

  4. Sewere wrote:

    Wendi said,

    HOWEVER, we as consumers are responsible as well. people can do their own research and look for music that is not played on the radio. i do it myself all the time. but many choose not to.

    That depends on who “we” are. The majority (I think the number that’s being bandied around is about 70-80%) of commercial rap is marketed to white boys with disposable income. When the majority of black folk raise our voices we would only be able to affect a small portion of the market.

    i think this is the time for us to seize what the media has given us, whether or not their motives come from the place we want them to, and run with it.

    Unfortunately, I think you overestimate the power black folks have over the media, because if we did we wouldn’t have to hear the likes of Beck, O’Reilly and Limbaugh continue to air their racism.

  5. Sewere wrote:

    I should also add that Michael Eric Dyson has always admonished those in the black community who have supported racist and sexist depictions of black women AND men. To lay the blame on black folks or ask black folks to be the ones to maneuver our way out of exploitation by using our (almost) negligible market power, ignores the reality of our sexist and racist society and renders any valid criticism incomplete (which is exactly MED has been doing for as long as I can remember).

  6. April wrote:

    Beautiful. :)

  7. Versai wrote:

    have been complaining about the sexist and racist aspects of hip hop for years and have not found adequate media support. now that we have it

    I think Mr. Dyson’s point is that we (the black community/people who want to “clean up” isms in music/whomever the “we” could be) do NOT have media support. Media is supporting the status quo. It’s not that they have a different reason for wanting to reach the same goal–the goal is different (to cast the spotlight away from itself, the guest, and the audience who helped keep IMUS on the air.)

    Now, if there were media folks who wanted to help–they wouldn’t be going to the rap or hiphop community at all–they would be focusing on the machine that helped build IMUS.

  8. wendi wrote:

    so then maybe a better question is…what is to be done about it? if people are not happy with the motivation for the media to point out the problems in mainstream hip hop, fine, but what is the action that is to be taken next in order to weed out the problems? also, when i refer to media “support,” i am refering primarily to the fact that they are finally calling attention to aspects of hip hop/rap as it stands that are negative to the black community. i don’t see the problem with using that to our advantage. one of the biggest issues when attempting to defeat what people consider a community ill is division amid the protest.

    with regard to this statement: “When the majority of black folk raise our voices we would only be able to affect a small portion of the market,” i agree, but i think it’s different in this case because the media is arguing the same point: mainstream hip hop tends to denigrate women and the black community.

    also, with regard to the comment regarding the consumers of hip hop…yes, white males do make up a large portion of the consumer market. BUT you have to keep in mind that the aforementioned statistics don’t in any way indicate that blacks and other people of color do not listen to hip hop. those are just statistics regarding purchasing of the music. that does not account for bootlegs, radio play, watching rap music on television, or concert attendance. consumerism also can take on a more figurative meaning here as well because it’s not the white community that’s, in turn, digesting the message conveyed and pouring liquor on naked girls on the stage at concerts (save maybe a KISS backstage tryst here and there). Long story short, the buying consumer statistics don’t matter in the long run when the biggest social affect is had on the black community, not the white community. we also cannot act as if rappers are FORCED to perpetuate the stereotypes and negative images that they do. they have other options, but the call for money is louder than that of community needs…UNLESS we possibly take the opportunity to work with the media for longterm goals as they are now stating a similar message.

  9. Versai wrote:

    Wendi wrote:

    They are finally calling attention to aspects of hip hop/rap as it stands that are negative to the black community.

    Actually, the media points it out everytime a white person gets “in trouble” for saying something racist (or, ahem, racially insensitive).

    We can’t “use it to our advantage” because the goal is to shut us up about racism/sexism/etc in overall American culture - not to actual stop it (in the black community or anywhere else).

    Something else will happen (maybe Madonna and Angelina will have an adoptathon) and the media will forget about rap, hiphop, and stereotypes. Then, the next time a white gets in hot water in regards to race, Media will point to hiphop/rap music (or a black comedian) again–and act like they’ve just stumbled onto the problem.

    What’s to be done? We can start by defining what “the problem” is? (Certain words? Because a skillful artist can write a song with sexist/racist/homophic themes without using a “bad” word.) Also, what are the social affects of rap and hip hop (positive or negative) on the black community? Does anyone really know? Is it having more influence on this generation than black explotation movies (talk about ho’s and pimps!) had on a previous generation?

  10. wendi wrote:

    i think this is a really important question, Versai: ” Is it having more influence on this generation than black explotation movies (talk about ho’s and pimps!) had on a previous generation?”

    To be honest, all of these images of blacks in the United States that we see in film, music, theatre, etc that we deem negative are leftovers from ante-bellum racist (blackface) stereotypes (like the mammy, the jezebel, zip coon, etc) that blacks did not have a hand in initially creating, but that in the present continue to act out. i think THAT is the negative effect: that we take the image of self that is projected ONTO us and have accepted as AS US (insofar as we now regurgitate it back to the viewing public as a part of black “popular culture”). it’s as if the actors have just changed hands. the blackface performers took off their makeup and handed the cork to blacks…who continue to apply it in the present, even though the blackness they already have doesn’t require a blackening up or a grotesque costume. so yeah, that’s what I find to be the problem…and i think that it goes back to imus…he (white person) says something, we say it’s bad, black person says something bad and there is minimal public response because it is now what we have grown to expect b/c we are told that is a part of who we are…that’s offensive and problematic…that is the problem. the definition of self needs to be left to the community, and i think some people are trying to re-define those terms without using imagery/ideas/behavior we are expected to incorporate into performance and into our concept of self…it’s like a grand scheme, cyclical, self-fulfilling prophechy that we need to find a way out of … but i digress…sorry.

    and yes, the media latches on to whatever is hot at the time, but i still think that people can take this moment as a potential catalyst to further action. i am not saying we should be dependent upon the media by any means, but i think we should use this 15 minutes of fame and take it further…

  11. Gem wrote:

    While we’re focusing on White America, once again, we are missing an opportunity to police our own culture. I think we are so offended that white people turned the glare of the spot light back on us that we once again have missed an opportunity to coalesce around the concept that commercial Hip Hop is lining the packets of rich white-run media companies and a few African American “artists” at the the exspense of the hearts, minds, and souls of young African American children.

    WhatAboutOurDaughters.Org

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.