Radar Online’s list of racial stereotypes in the movies

by Carmen Van Kerckhove

Radar Online just published a great list called From Borat to Mammy: The top ten stereotypes in cinema history:

Hollywood has a long history of racial insensitivity—stereotypes are its stock in trade. But, as with Borat, watchdog groups are too quick to sound the alarm when things get out of hand. Unfortunately for film-goers with less-fragile constitutions, some of the most deliciously offensive characters in cinema have been relegated to the dustbin as a result. Where were the Golden Globes when Long Duk Dong dropped his L’s in Sixteen Candles? It just doesn’t seem fair. Come with us on a tour of Hollywood’s walk of shame, where we gaze, slack-jawed, upon the ten best stereotypes ever captured on film.

(Hat tip to Angry Asian Man.) So who’s on the list?

Long Duk Dong
From: Sixteen Candles, 1984
Played By: Gedde Watanabe
Groups Offended: Asians, exchange students

Speedy Gonzales
From: The Looney, Looney, Looney Bugs Bunny Movie, 1981; various Looney Tunes and Merry Melodies animated shorts
Voiced By: Mel Blanc
Groups Offended: Mexicans, mice

James ‘Buffalo Bill’ Gumb
From: The Silence of the Lambs, 1991
Played By: Ted Levine
Groups Offended: Gays, transsexuals, lesbians, serial killers, cannibals

Dick Hallorann
From:The Shining, 1980
Played By: Scatman Crothers
Groups Offended: African-Americans, mystics, Lady Cleo, Dionne Warwick, most of the Psychic Friends Network

Jar Jar Binks
From: Star Wars: Phantom Menace, 1999; Attack of the Clones, 2002; Revenge of the Sith, 2005)
Voiced By: Ahmed Best
Groups Offended: Jamaicans, nerds

Pagoda
From: The Royal Tenenbaums, 2001
Played By: Kumar Pallana
Groups Offended: Indians, hipsters

Grand Vizier Jafar
From: Aladdin, 1992
Voiced By: Jonathan Freeman
Groups Offended: Arabs, street urchins

Caiaphas
From: The Passion of the Christ, 2004
Played By: Mattia Sbragia
Groups Offended: Jews, Jews for Jesus

Mr. Yunioshi
From: Breakfast at Tiffany’s, 1961
Played By: Mickey Rooney
Groups Offended: Asians

Mammy
From: Gone With the Wind, 1939
Played By: Hattie McDaniel
Groups Offended: African Americans

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • NewsVine
  • Current
  • email
  • Print

Comments

  1. ren wrote:

    Goddamn you Long Duk Dong, goddamn you. I had to put up with Long Duk Dong shit for years in middle school and it wasn’t even until high school that I finally watched Sixteen Candles and realized where it was all coming from. Gedde Watanabe holds my scorn forever. And also for Turner Broadcasting for running Sixteen Candles on repeat every week for the past 10 years. Stop already.

    This is certainly a diverse list. But when it comes to using crappy stereotypes I’m going to unscientifically claim the crown for the Asians. If you think you’ve been crapped on more in the cinematic world we can debate it to see who gets the revered “crapped on” distinction.

    Every film of Fu Manchu and all his little evil yellow henchmen
    Every Charlie Chan film
    Anna May Wong in Daughter of the Dragon
    Ming from Flash Gordon
    Suzy Wong — “oh mishter, me good gul weally”
    Nancy Kwan from Tamahine
    Eiko Ando in The Barbarian and the Geisha
    Every Asian that was in Year of the Dragon
    John Wayne as Genghis Kahn in The Conqueror — “me think tartar woman is for me!”
    Lotus Blossom from Teahouse of the August Moon
    Miss Saigon
    Very fucking incarnation of Madame Butterfly
    Tai-Pan
    Asians as depicted in Menace II Society and Do the Right Thing
    The Asian Clerk from Falling Down
    China Gate… dear god, all of it
    Every Asian woman in Sayonara
    All the samurai who had to get shot down and sacrificially die in hordes to leave Tom Cruise as the last true samurai of Japan

    And that’s just hitting on the films where Asians are “represented”. We haven’t gotten into the films where Asians are just set pieces or invisible.

  2. Sizwe_X wrote:

    Nice list ren, but I’m surprised you forgot “Short Round” of Temple of Doom fame. Fucking A, hearing, “Indy! Indy!”, “Hang on wady, we goin’ fo’ a wide!”, and “No time fo’ luv, Docta Jones!” throughout school made the killing rage rise up in me. Thanks, Hollywood!

  3. Jay wrote:

    Speaking of Short Round, does anybody remember Jonathan Ke Quan’s role in the Goonies? Does anybody remember the Goonies?

    He was gadget guy, but I don’t remember him being all that much of a stereotype in there.

  4. ren wrote:

    Hahah, ah Short Round. He was better in the Goonies for sure. For some reason all I can remember about that film is Chunk and a Butterfinger.

    After discussing this post with some other Asians I have, to my horror and regret, forgot to mention a beloved Asian character. The “Me so horny, me love you long time, American GI… five dollah” girl from Full Metal Jacket. Now why didn’t her career ever take off? Thank you for crushing the self-esteem of many a Asian women in a mere 62 seconds of screen time.

    Does anybody find it weird how we the Asian world as depicted by Hollywood can simultaneously be full of sexually promiscuous insatiable Asian women and Asian guys that can’t get any? What a wacky people those Asians.

  5. Gandalf Mantooth wrote:

    Watanabe has tried to make amends, hasn’t he?

    Though Hiro in Heroes gets mad love I don’t see him as much more than Duk Dong with super powers.

  6. berrybrowne wrote:

    to me real progress will be when “groups offended” includes all racial groups. i was offended/irrritated during breakfast at tiffany’s, 16 candles, aladdin, and speedy gonzales, even though i’m not asian, latino or arab american. let’s all get irate together!

  7. Lyonside wrote:

    Berrybrowne:

    Nothing to add here but
    *applause* *applause**applause*

  8. this justin wrote:

    My friend and I were just talking about this and how more often than not, these amazingly racist portrayals are “awarded” with accolades like Golden Globes and Oscars.

  9. Sewere wrote:

    I swear I wanted to throw something at the TV when I saw Flavor Flav… And almost everytime Carlos Mencia does his “wetback” shtick, I get the distinct feeling he’s trying to pull a Latino version of Chris Rock’s “Black People vs. N*%*s” crap.

    I’m not even going to go near his hideously Anti-Arab “blow them with a nuclear weapon” racist jokes. Idiot.

  10. Jay wrote:

    Oh yes, I remember another Gedde Watanabe gem: he was in Weird Al’s movie UHF (Weird Al had a movie?!), and played a Japanese Karate Dojo instructor and all the fun stuff that entails (the movie features, among others, the wonderful Michael Richards, and yes, that was sarcasm). By the way, he actually saves the day.

    The only redeeming moment was in that Wheel of Fish segment where he taunted the contestant for not getting the right answer.

    I do have thoughts on Masi Oka, but need to coherently gather them.

  11. merq wrote:

    berrybrowne:

    Unfortunately, that’s what we’re faced with in today’s America. I can’t count the number of times people react in shock when I object to hearing racist comments about non-blacks.

    The other day, a (white) co-worker actually spent a good 10 minutes trying to ascertain whether or not I had any Jewish roots when I got mad at his “Jew = tightwad” rhetoric.

    That’s what you get when you worry more about being “offensive” than racist. If a man yells “nigger” in the forest with no one around, is he still racist?

    Sewere:
    Forget Mencia. Seriously.

  12. kim wrote:

    I don’t know about the Mexicans/mice thing. I find it kind of unfunny and appalling, as they scurrilous animal( vermin) is not introduced with any other breakdown of groups offended.

    Merq: yeah. gotcha.

  13. justin wrote:

    I’m going to break from the we all need to get irate together sentiment and say that Polynesians in America need to stand up for themselves.
    Ren, what is Tamahine? Did Nancy Kwan play a Maori woman named Tama, was Tama-tu the sequel, should someone tell Tama Iti? ;)
    People in NZ really care that Indians are Asians cause England tells us so, most Nzer’s would laugh at the way America treats Polynesians. If I were smarter I would make a super cool joke about the ‘strategic essentialism’.

  14. Colin wrote:

    merq: You’re amazingly, stupendously right-on.

    “Political correctness” has been the greatest
    single device to shut down actual race discussion in American history, and it’s in full effect on college campus, the term is.

    People of all types and stripes will act out the most shocking and sad of stereotypes and call their critics “politically correct” and act indignant in defense of their racist words and actions, even here in the halls of the enlightened.

  15. tmk wrote:

    ren:

    Thanks for an amazing list!! However, you must also not forget all the extras in various movies/tv/commercials who are just as bad– ah those silent and mysterious Asians!

  16. gatamala wrote:

    ”Speaking of Short Round, does anybody remember Jonathan Ke Quan’s role in the Goonies? Does anybody remember the Goonies?

    He was gadget guy, but I don’t remember him being all that much of a stereotype in there. ”

    ….his name was……”Data”……

  17. liberty wrote:

    I noticed that you missed a rather blantant jab, complete with racial slurs, at Eastern Euopeans in Sixteen Candles. While the obviously offensive “Long Duk Dong” character is often noted, the “oily bohunk” husband-to-be of Samantha’s sister seems to go unnoticed. This racial epithet is used multiple times to desribe the fiance and his, very stereotypical, family. It seems that the cultural understanding of “who is white” has grown since 1984!

  18. Sopey-Dopey wrote:

    Oh yeah, you also missed another blantant jab; this one towards African Americans in Sixteen Candles. While Samantha and her friend are walking in the hall at school, Samnatha says she wants “a black one;” her friend says ” a black guy!?” Samantha meant a black Trans-Am (80’s folks) I’m not black; however, I’m Mexican, Fillipino and German (quite a wonderful mix, I may say) but, whenever I see any stereotype towards any race and/or culture (even white)..I get a bit offended, but that’s unfortunately our culture in this county.

  19. Geny wrote:

    Oh and of course who can forget the ever-so-funny and endearing “buddy” movies; Rush Hour and Shanghai Noon…Jackie Chan, since when do you need help kickin a$$??? Chris Tucker should’ve been shot…Owen Wilson, no comment, not since Starsky and Hutch…so much racism, so little time…

  20. Melody wrote:

    Sopey-Dopey, I noticed that too. What made the jab toward African Americans in Sixteen Candles worse is how they allowed Molly Ringwold to respond to her ignorant friend’s shock and dismay. If I remember correctly, Molly says “No, no, no. A black Trans-Am with a pink guy inside.” As if to backtrack from previous insult. Backtracking is the worst!!!

  21. Emmeaki wrote:

    Jonathan Ke Quan’s character in Goonies was “Data” and he was always inventing different gadgets–yes he was the stereotypical nerdy, math/science whiz kid.

  22. Tadakatsu Honda wrote:

    Good job on this dude.

  23. Daena wrote:

    What I don’t understand is how openly offended people get about these racial slurs, yet Hollywood keeps spewing them out like uncontrollable diarrhea.

    Sorry for that mental image.

  24. anti-stereotype wrote:

    And speaking of racist stereotypes….

    http://www.reelbadarabs.com/